We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
All reviews fried seafood fries filet snapper hamburger tacos chicken sea gulls cafeteria style new york city pina coladas are fine dining view of the water high school city island avenue been coming here for years half shell
I have had the shrimp and the fish filet both nicely done and fresh. the fries unfortunately are sometimes cooked up too far ahead and are not crispy.
If I were to find one negative it's the coleslaw. It's at the bottom of the fried...More
This is the happy place my parents took the whole family to eat when I was a child. I always remember sitting out by the pier eating, laughing, and enjoying the delicious food. I recently revisited Johnny's on a trip back to New York and...More
Been years since I've been on the island and visited Johnny's. Brought my date here to have a late lunch and as always it was very busy and nowhere to sit inside, we would've of sat outside but it started to get breezy and cold....More
Visiting City Island and Johnny's Reef was like going back in time. Away from the hustle and bustle of New York City even though its a part of the Bronx but unlike the Bronx. It was more like a small New England type of nautical...More
This is the second time I have been here last time was over 5 years ago - things have improved more choice and the portions are good the view from outside are lovely - just remember to bring mosquito spray
absolutely lovely view, outside enjoying almost fried everything. The snapper, onion rings, calamari were near perfection. Had to add steamed lobster tails and clam chowder. quick and easy to order, despite the long line of hungry diners. impressive near picture of perfection how smooth the...More
Went to Johnny's as a British Tourist, and couldn't believe the quality of the food we were served with. We ordered the fried meals of Fillet and Shrimp which are both served with Fries, Coleslaw (a tiny little tub of cabbage rather) and a piece...More
When we crave fried seafood, we go to Johnny's Reef on City Island. We have been customers for years. This unpretentious, order at the counter, cash only spot at the end of City Island Avenue is popular with Bronxites, civil service workers, and those who...More
In the month of July, 2018 my husband and I went to NY for vacations. Our first craving was for fresh and delicious seafood in City Island, Bronx, NY. We took with us, my two grandaughters (12 & 14 years old), and my niece (58)....More