They never disappoint. Food is great, drinks are great and the service is the best to be found anywhere. The servers go out of their way to accommodate you over and above normal limits. I can’t say enough about this place and can’t wait to...More
You are always greeted warmly by both the valets and staff of this restaurant. Service is excellent. Delicious vege plate and bread appears as soon as you sit down! Drinks are generous and well mixed. There are so many seafood choices on the menu it...More
We started by ordering mix drinks, they were so bad that we had to send it back for another one, that was bad too, so we gave up. I think only beer or wine might be a better choice. We ordered surf & turf, the...More
I felt like I had come home to this Jewel in City Island - I celebrated all my birthdays here when I lived in the Bronx and it was exactly as I remembered it - the twin lobster tail seashore with crab meat stuffing was...More
Every location on City Island charges about the same, but I feel this place is actually worth it. It's the best of them all. I like to go and eat and I like to get food around the holidays.
At first I thought the prices were rather high. But then a large plate of snacks to start with arrived: olives, marinated mushrooms, an eggplant dish, etc. plus 3 types of bread including garlic bread. My dish (sole meuniere) was very good and plenty. My...More
Catching up on old times with good friends in a very relaxed and not rushed lunch. The service was attentive and their teamwork was evident. Stuffed clams and fried calamari were perfect for appetizers with well made drinks. The salmon and fried scallops for the...More
Come to City Island. You won't be disappointed. First Time at the Seashore Restaurant...I ordered the broiled scallops with shrimp, my daughter the shrimp stuffed crab meat..my grandson chicken fingers with fries..everything delicious..service excellent...can't miss it first restaurant on your left when u enter City...More
Me and my family were looking for a restaurant to celebrate a 50th birthday. Someone recommended the Seashore Restaurant. So I looked up the reviews. The only negative that I really noticed was the service. But in picking a restaurant service is a plus but...More
My Family and I had a horrible experience at this restaurant. The waiter was rude and dismissive when we told him that we were ready to order. Our food took a while to come and when it did it was lukewarm. We never saw the...More
know better book better go better 