Had the worst service ever! This used to be my favorite restaurant, i was there today to celebrate my birthday, i waited more than 30 minutes for my food, people that sat after us ate before us. Finally the food arrives, the so called manager (blonde lady) passed by an ask if everything is ok (i haven't even taken the... More 

Been there a number of times over the years. just returned. Better than ever. seafood selection is great. service very good. prices reasonable. Quantity is amazing, quality is excellent. especially the scallops and shrimp and flounder

Visited for lunch this past weekend and it was very warm and slightly crowded for 4/5pm crowd. I had the seafood combination platter and while it was beautiful to look at it was a little tasteless and very buttery. Prices were overrated for the dishes. Service was not at its best during this timeframe.

The food was delicious service was great! Loved sitting in the back even though it was raining it didn't matter. Pina Coladas were amazing!

After a long hiatus away from City Island, I had occasion to visit this lovely waterfront restaurant. The waiter Luis was attentive, friendly, helpful and all around added to the enjoyment of our visit. We were a large group of cackling women and Luis was patient and courteous to everyone of us. Half of the group dined on the lobster... More 

Atmosphere is amazing, yesterday was such a lovely day it was nice to have the option to sit outside. Food was on point, only thing if I knew how big the appetizer was i would have skipped it, getting bread, pickled veggies before you order, then salad and a side with your main course I really didn't need to order... More 

The food was delicious, and they give you a large serving so come hungry, I also had a few margaritas which were also on point, the outside view is a plus

First, it's not a yuppie's kind of place. They should go somewhere else. Me, I liked it, and would go back. We read here some scary comments about the valets, don't know if they are true, so found a parking spot on the street. The restaurant is HUUGE, I can't imagine this place at capacity, how they deal with all... More 

Our party of 3 were there yesterday 6/5/2016 and while it was raining outside, inside was a slice of heaven on the waterfront. We were immediately seated, received ice water shortly thereafter and looked over the very very large menu. Literally there is something for everyone at this beautiful restaurant. Our service was very good, very professional and attentive. I've... More