I stopped here on a whim while taking a ride. Extensive menu !!! I got a pulled pork sandwich with fries and beans. The pork itself was very tender but in my opinion it lacked smoke and flavor. HOWEVER… The sauce was very good and...made up for it ! Beans were really good and fries were cooked in fresh oil. Nice corn bread. I’m going to stop back with my family and try other things.More

My husband and I were traveling with our dog and were absolutely delighted to find this place . . . the food was delicious and there were plenty of side dishes to chose from which is always a bonus. Our dog was allowed to dine...with us at the outside tables which were nice and covered so we weren't out in the hot sun. Staff was very friendly and even brought our dog water one day when we left our in the car. Our dog can be temperamental at times but he loved everyone on staff which says a lot. We went back three times during the course of the week we were there, had different meals each time and found all of them to be delicious.More

Having been told I should try this out-of-the-way spot by my girlfriend, we made our way to 58 Main BBQ one day last week. The inside looked cozy and the folks were friendly. We ordered one of their combo platters from the menu, feeling that...it would be enough for a lunch for both of us. And it was. The platter included 3 pieces of 58's ribs, 1/4 lb of brisket and 1/4 lb of pulled pork, with their BBQ beans and house made chips as sides. The St. Louis ribs were super tender and meaty, the pulled pork was also tender and very tasty, but the the beef brisket was a big disappointment. You'd expect to be presented with 2-3 slices of brisket, but instead what we got was a small pile of shredded and chopped up meat. I have lived in Kansas City, have traveled many times to Dallas and have eaten BBQ in both cities. 58 Main BBQ misses the mark by quite a bit, but, that said, I would go back to see if that might just have been a bad day.More

It's hard to find BBQ in the North that compares to what you find down South but this is one of the best that I have found up here. Lots of menu options. Generous portions. Been their several times. One of my favorites in the...area.More

Three of us went for a recent dinner. We were quickly seated by the hostess, so take note that it was crowded. After sitting for over 30 minutes without being greeted by a hostess and watching other parties enter after us, and have their order...taken, I asked their waitress to let our waitress know that we were ready to place our order. Another 10 minutes goes by when the other waitress returns and tells us that our waitress was "busy" and she was going to take the order, which she did (burger and 2 sandwiches). Again, while waiting over another 50 minutes and watching others who came after us being served, we finally received our meals. Out of frustration, we took them with us. And not even an apology. On top of this, the food was terrible. If you want to save yourself 90 minutes of waiting and eater better food, I would recommend that you go to MacDonalds..More

I could not go wrong in choosing 58 Main for bridal shower of 20 girls. Menu was chosen for it’s excellent reviews and it worked perfectly. As shower was on Saturday, requested pick up was Friday... all on time. All heating instructions were included for...the following day. Many guests were from out of town (different states) and they Raved about the food...excellente. Saved time for the hostess, too!! I would not hesitate to order again - Thanks again, Marc & SarahMore

We went there a couple weeks ago with my daughter and son-in-law. We ordered a variety of items from Burgers to Ribs and pasta, all of which was plentiful and very good tasting. Our waiter didn't write our order done and "nailed it", very impressive.

College town but not full of rowdy college kids. Service was good, staff is friendly. Lots of choices,, good food.

They were able to accommodate a hockey team and parents at the last minute. Staff was friendly and fast. I had the fish sandwich. It was really good. The portions some of the other people had were good sized and looked really good. I would...definitely go back.More

Awesome food. You can tell the bbque sauce and their wing sauce was homemade definately will be going back. Not as expensive as i thought

We were able to get reservations in the street side room for 16. Service was attentive and prompt. We were all served and ate within 1 hour and 15 minutes. Everyone was pleased with their meals. Thank you

This is a good place to bring family and friends. The good here is good and the service has always been good.