We were two couples passing through the area and spending a night in Brockport. We chose 58 Main based on reviews, but the Uber driver who took us there assured us that we had made quite a good choice. The restaurant was busy, so that...was a recommendation as well. The BBQ is made in a smokehouse just across the alley from the restaurant, so this was the real deal. It probably isn't a good choice for someone on a low-cholesterol diet, but the food was great — good quality meat, well cooked, and flavourful. My wife chose a 1/4 rack ribs and I chose a brisket dinner. Portions were large. Dinners came with sides. The beer selection was excellent. Cocktails were available as well; my wife enjoyed a good margarita. Service was efficient and friendly.More