We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
LOVE this pizza. We travel from 3 towns away (Pawling, NY) just to have their pizza (and there are 3 pizza places in Pawling!). The pizza is always hot and fresh. Friendly staff and lots of room in the dining room. Every Friday night -...Gaetanos!More
I have tried all the pizza shops around Brewster area , including Route 22 area and this is hands down the best. Consistently. The crust alone is a work of art before they add the just perfect sauce and toppings ( all always fresh). The...taste always reflects the generous use of high quality ingredients. Once upon a time they had a worthy competitor over the moon over on Route 22 but that place changed hands and chefs and the quality just ain’t there anymore. Gaetano’s still does right by you.More
We stop here regularly and have never had a bad meal. Today was no exception. Their small salads are quite big but work perfectly with a slice of pizza. I grabbed the buffalo chicken and my wife had the chicken pram pizza. Hers was loaded...with chicken. Both were excellent.More
I'm not from the area stop by to visit somebody and was very happy with the type of pizzas and the selection they had a large variety I had three different slices all delicious staff was very helpful courteous. Nice cannoli to cap off the...meal. Would definitely recommend this placeMore
We had a pizza and chicken parm sandwich. The level of salt was unbearable. Half and hour after eating 2 slices of pizza, my throat still burns and I can't shake the overwhelming lingering taste of salt. We called to advise them of the problem,...and the only response was "Thanks, click". They couldn't have cared less. By By Gaetano. Never again.More