We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
Order Online
OR
Reserve a Table
2
Mon, 5/25
8:00 PM

Menu

STARTERS‏
Onion Soup Au Gratin
Gruyère crouton‏
$6.95
Tavern Market Salad
Baby greens, garden vegetables choice of dressing
$6.95
House Caesar Salad
Crisp romaine, caesar dressing, parmesan crouton
$6.95
Baby Field Green Salad
Dried cranberries, candied walnuts, maytag bleu cheese, balsamic vinaigrette
$7.95
Iceberg Wedge
Warm bacon, red onion, chopped tomato, blue cheese dressing
$7.95
Arugula Salad
Roasted beets, goat cheese, toasted almonds, raspberry vinaigrette
$8.95
Burrata Mozzarella
Creamy mozzarella,‏ balsamic reduction, basil infused olive oil, grape tomatoes
$9.95
Chilled Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail
Bloody mary cocktail sauce
$14.95
“Mim's” Classic Chicken Wings
Hot sauce, bleu cheese dressing, celery
$9.95
Pretzel Baked Brie
Brie stuffed pretzel, brown sugar, fig jam
$8.95
TAVERN MUSSEL POTS
Mussels Fra Diavlo
Spicy pomodoro
$15.95
Mussels Au Vin Blanc
White wine, fresh herb lemon garlic butter
$15.95
Mussels Provençale
Tomato, garlic, onion, white wine, butter, olives, toasted bread crumbs
$15.95
Mussels Casino
Shallots, garlic, butter, roasted red pepper, bacon, white wine
$15.95
MAIN PLATE SALADS‏
Tavern Caesar Salad
Crisp romaine, caesar dressing, parmesan, crouton
$11.95
Tuscan Grilled Vegetable Salad
Zucchini, asparagus, artichoke hearts, roasted tomatoes, portobello mushrooms, goat cheese, baby greens, stone mustard vinaigrette
$13.95
Grilled Salmon Salad
Portobello mushrooms, fresh mozzarella, grilled asparagus, toasted pine nuts, roasted red peppers, arugula, balsamic vinaigrette
$17.95
Grilled Steak Salad
Gorgonzola, crispy onions, roasted tomatoes, baby spinach stone mustard vinaigrette
$17.95
Chopped Cobb Salad
Grilled chicken, tomato, red onion, bacon, cucumber, maytag bleu, cheddar, sliced egg, mixed greens, bleu cheese dressing
$15.95
SANDWICHES
All served w/ choice of french fries, sweet potato fries or substitute a house salad -63
Grilled 10 Oz. Prime Angus Burger
Exclusive blend, brioche bun
$12.95
Baja Fish Tacos
Grilled or blackened shaved cabbage, mango salsa, queso fresco, cilantro lime crema
$13.95
Chicken Ciabatta
Grilled or milanese chicken, baby arugula, roasted red peppers, prosciutto, fresh mozzarella & balsamic glaze
$13.95
Grilled Steak Sandwich
Skirt steak, crispy onions, melted mozzarella, luger sauce, garlic bread
$17.95
Grilled Shrimp BLT Wrap
Grilled shrimp, applewood bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo
$16.95
MAIN‏
Linguini Seafood
Jumbo shrimp, mussels, calamari, scallops, white wine garlic olive oil or fra diavlo
$23.95
Side caesar $+4.95
Market salad $+4.95
Rigatoni & Blackened Skirt Steak
Spinach, grilled portobello mushrooms, gorgonzola, porcini mushroomsage cream sauce
$19.95
Side caesar $+4.95
Market salad $+4.95
Hickory Smoked BBQ Baby Back Ribschoice of Side
$24.95
Side caesar $+4.95
Market salad $+4.95
Lemon Sole Oreganata
Jumbo shrimp, mussels, tomatoes, sautéed spinach, roasted garlic lemon olive oil, angel hair
$24.95
Side caesar $+4.95
Market salad $+4.95
Pan Seared Sea Scallops
Shrimp & asparagus risotto, shaved granna, white truffle oil
$27.95
Side caesar $+4.95
Market salad $+4.95
Stone Mustard Grilled Salmon
Warm grilled vegetables, goat cheese, stone mustard glaze
$24.95
Side caesar $+4.95
Market salad $+4.95
Mama's Homemade Chicken Pot Pie
Roasted chicken breast, carrots, peas, potatoes, fresh sage béchamel sauce, puff pastry crust
$16.95
Side caesar $+4.95
Market salad $+4.95
Zucchini Linguini
Baby shrimp, roasted tomato-white wine garlic broth
$24.95
Side caesar $+4.95
Market salad $+4.95
Grilled Montauk Swordfish
Lemon oregano‏ olive oil, pancetta, roasted red peppers, garlic broccoli rabe, roasted potatoes
$26. 95
Side caesar $+4.95
Market salad $+4.95
Apricot Glazed Salmon
Arugula salad, almonds, goat cheese, red wine vinaigrette
$24.95
Side caesar $+4.95
Market salad $+4.95
CHOP HOUSE SELECTION
Side Caesar or Market Salad
$3.95
Asparagus $+1.95
Shrimp risotto $+1.95
16 Oz USDA Prime Ny Sirloin
$34.95
Asparagus $+1.95
Shrimp risotto $+1.95
18 Oz “Cowboy “ Bone-in Rib Eye
$36.95
Asparagus $+1.95
Shrimp risotto $+1.95
Marinated Skirt Steak
$26.95
Asparagus $+1.95
Shrimp risotto $+1.95
8 Oz Filet Mignon
$35.95
Asparagus $+1.95
Shrimp risotto $+1.95
Chicken Breast
$18.95
Asparagus $+1.95
Shrimp risotto $+1.95
MARKET FISH SELECTION‏
Grilled, Blackened Broiled or Sautéed
Choice of:roasted garlic scampi francaise oreganata honey mustard  fresh salsa
Asparagus $+1.95
Shrimp risotto $+1.95
Ahi Tuna
$27.95
Salmon
$24.95
Jumbo Shrimp
$26.95
Lemon Sole
$23.95
Sea Scallops
$27.95
SIDES
Roasted Potatoes
$5.00
Baked Potato
$5.00
Mashed Potatoes
$5.00
Sweet Potato Fries
$5.00
Tavern Fries
$5.00
Grilled Sweet Potatoes
$5.00
Whipped Sweet Potato
$5.00
Asparagus
$1.95
Sautéed Broccoli
$5.00
Creamed Spinach
$5.00
About
Long Island's most popular neighborhood restaurants, Mill Creek Tavern serves seasonal robustly flavored, American cuisine in a relaxed setting of casual elegance. We offer a full dinner menu with daily specials in the dining room and the bar. Behind the bar, an outstanding wine list, local micro-brews and a large selection of hand-crafted specialty cocktails are offered. Private parties, large groups & special events are welcome, with private dining & event space available. Mill Creek Tavern is known for welcoming guests with excellent value and warm hospitality. We also have an off-premise catering division called Mill Creek Catering & Events. From pig roasts and lobster bakes to formal weddings.
PRICE RANGE
$15 - $30
Meals
Dinner, Late Night, Drinks
CUISINES
American, Steakhouse, Bar, Seafood, Pub
FEATURES
Takeout, Seating, Parking Available, Street Parking, Free Off-Street Parking, Television, Highchairs Available, Wheelchair Accessible, Serves Alcohol, Full Bar, Accepts American Express, Accepts Mastercard, Accepts Visa, Free Wifi, Accepts Discover, Reservations, Table Service, Accepts Credit Cards
Reviews (188)
Filter reviews
187 results
Traveler rating
123
47
9
5
3
Traveler type
Time of year
LanguageEnglish
Traveler rating
123
47
9
5
3
Show reviews that mention
All reviews chicken pot pie risotto ribs fondue steak salad seafood comfort food nice atmosphere love this place never disappoints granny smith apples entree selections reserve a table favorite places local gem restaurant staff
Selected filters
FilterEnglish
Updating list...
Reviewed March 7, 2020 via mobile

Tonight came to Mill Creek for dinner and to my surprise ordered the special ...Chatham Cod Piccata amazing piece of fish served with asparagus capers tomato with a lovely white wine butter sauce To die for highly recommend it Again another great meal at the...More

Date of visit: March 2020
Helpful?
Reviewed February 11, 2020

Very homey atmosphere, Beautiful Place, Great Food, Excellent Service. Outstanding German food on the menu but that's not all Something for everyone. i get there every chance I can.

Date of visit: January 2020
Helpful?
Rich3636, Owner at Mill Creek Tavern, responded to this reviewResponded March 4, 2020

Hi Frank. Thanks for your kind words and five star review. We are grateful for guests like yourself. All the best - Rich

Reviewed January 20, 2020

Such a nice atmosphere having dinner by the fireplace warm and cozy along with excellent food ,everyone enjoyed their apps and entree selections and desserts ,we brought a couple who had never been here and they are in love with this place now and said...More

Date of visit: January 2020
Helpful?
Rich3636, Owner at Mill Creek Tavern, responded to this reviewResponded March 4, 2020

Hi Joe. Thanks for introducing your friends to Mill Creek. We look forward to serving you again soon - Rich

Reviewed December 29, 2019 via mobile

Met a friend for dinner after the Christmas holiday and decided to go to the Mill Creek Tavern I ordered the Scallop Shrimp risotto which was amazing with a Cesar salad and the other order was Shrimp wrap which was delicious as well Would highly...More

Date of visit: December 2019
Helpful?
Rich3636, Owner at Mill Creek Tavern, responded to this reviewResponded March 4, 2020

Hi Sharon. Thanks for your kind words and awesome review. All the best - Rich

Reviewed August 15, 2019 via mobile

My husband and I have frequented this local restaurant near our home for at least 2 years now. The food is always freshly prepared and delicious! The servers are also very pleasant and accommodating. We usually order pasta with clams, fresh mussels, or another seafood...More

Date of visit: June 2019
Helpful?1  
Rich3636, Owner at Mill Creek Tavern, responded to this reviewResponded December 10, 2019

Thanks for the 5 stars and kind words. I would also like to thank you for your loyalty for the past two years. All the best - Rich

Reviewed July 11, 2019

Went with tripadvisor recommendations and gave Mill Creek Tavern a try with friends on a Wednesday evening....we were seated right away with a reservation and the place was pretty busy (both the bar and restaurant)....service was very good, albeit a bit slow at times....place is...More

Date of visit: July 2019
Helpful?
Rich3636, Owner at Mill Creek Tavern, responded to this reviewResponded December 10, 2019

Thanks for taking the time out to post and thanks for the 5 stars. We are so happy the you found us. Hope to srr you soon - Rich

Reviewed July 5, 2019 via mobile

The food never disappoints! Whether it be Steak, Seafood, Pasta, or even a sandwich or burger, we have never had a meal that was not great. The owner and staff, especially Vanessa, always cater to our every need or want.

Date of visit: July 2019
Helpful?
Rich3636, Owner at Mill Creek Tavern, responded to this reviewResponded December 10, 2019

Thanks for the awesome 5 star review!! Sorry to respond so late :) Have a great day - Rich

Reviewed April 27, 2019

Best Muscles in White Wine Sauce on Long Island ,along with Scallops and Shrimp Risotto with asparagus ,Salmon with a apricot glaze and a Apple Crisp for dessert You can't beat it all so good ,This hidden Gem in Bayville is worth the trip ,you...More

Date of visit: April 2019
Helpful?
Rich3636, Owner at Mill Creek Tavern, responded to this reviewResponded May 7, 2019

Thanks Joe. You are a true ambassador to our brand. We are so grateful for your support . With Gratitude - Rich

Reviewed January 19, 2019

Delicious fish tacos! Nice salads too. Burger was fresh and juicy. Good happy hour specials on apps and drinks too. Bartender Andrea is great!! We will return.

Review collected in partnership with this restaurant
Date of visit: December 2018
Helpful?
Rich3636, Owner at Mill Creek Tavern, responded to this reviewResponded February 12, 2019

Thanks!!!

Reviewed January 17, 2019

great people, great food , never a disappointment nice atmosphere ,comfortable, food is very fresh ,clean

Review collected in partnership with this restaurant
Date of visit: December 2018
Helpful?
Rich3636, Owner at Mill Creek Tavern, responded to this reviewResponded February 12, 2019

Hi Leslie. Love the "Home town happiness" your the best!!! See you soon - Rich

View more reviews
Best nearby
Best nearby hotelsSee all
The Tides Motor Inn
43 reviews
2.67 miles away
The Mansion at Glen Cove
1,609 reviews
4.44 miles away
East Norwich Inn
132 reviews
4.51 miles away
Comfort Inn Syosset by Choice Hotels
277 reviews
7.06 miles away
Best nearby restaurantsSee all
The Crescent Beach Club
65 reviews
.27 miles away
Ocean
77 reviews
.27 miles away
Twin Harbors Restaurant
40 reviews
.31 miles away
Best nearby attractionsSee all
Bayville Scream Park
148 reviews
1.73 miles away
Shu Swamp Preserve - Charles T Church Nature Preserve
14 reviews
2.05 miles away
Sagamore Hill National Historic Site
484 reviews
2.86 miles away
Caumsett State Park
211 reviews
4.04 miles away
Questions & Answers
Ask a question
luckyman56
August 9, 2016|
AnswerShow all 5 answers
Response from wetherlee | Reviewed this property |
unfortunately, no. It is near the water, about a block away but not on the water. Wall's Wharf is on the water in Bayville, however, and offers a great menu for beach dining.
0
Votes
Is This Your Listing?
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.
Claim Your Free Listing