We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

The Fish Store


Ratings and reviews



Seafood, American
Lunch, Dinner
Takeout, Seating, Waitstaff, Serves Alcohol

Location and contact

Reviews (42)
Filter reviews
42 results
Traveler rating
Traveler type
Time of year
Traveler rating
See what travelers are saying:
Updating list...
1 - 10 of 42 reviews
Reviewed August 3, 2018 via mobile

We loved this place....we started off with salad and new england clam chowder...very very good...salad full of rich green leafs...clam chowder rich anf flavorful..then the coconut shrimp....Excellant.....I had the cedar wood salmon...and it was one of the best I've ever had...My wife had the Flounder...More

Date of visit: August 2018
Thank R J T
Reviewed May 16, 2018 via mobile

Went out with my husband, Two other adults and two kids. It was " Lobster Night" so three people ordered Lobster which was over cooked and rubbery. I ordered Mahi-Mahi on special and it was cooked to the point where chewing was of no use....More

Date of visit: May 2018
Thank Jbaron22
Reviewed August 8, 2017

Service was great, apps were OK, clam chowder good but the dinners not so good. Fish had no flavor and was dry. Except for specials meals are not inexpensive, would have cost the same to go to Red Lobster and the food there would have...More

Date of visit: August 2017
Thank 956pat956
Reviewed July 19, 2017 via mobile

Planned a dinner for 10. Surf and turf. Preordered 10 Brazilian Lobster Tails @ 14 to 16 Ounces each along with 200 Little Neck Clams. Our order was ready as promised, the tails were tender and tasty, while all 200 of the clams were sized...More

Date of visit: July 2017
1  Thank Dominic747
Reviewed June 25, 2017

The Fish Store catered our end of year lunch at our school. Many delicious dishes to be had. Especially liked the chicken francais. I also liked the shrimp skewers. People seemed to enjoy the mussels and clams also.

Date of visit: June 2017
Thank Susaneac
Reviewed April 15, 2017 via mobile

Situated on a corner in downtown Bayport this is the place to go for all your fresh fish needs. The aroma tells you immediately you're in the right place! Fish of all types are on display along with every accouterment . You can take anything...More

Date of visit: April 2017
Thank Felicia B
Reviewed February 4, 2017

Favorite thing about this place is the atmosphere. Small dining room with a few tables, the gentle beachy music and Fire Island aesthetic set the mood for a great seafood lunch or dinner. I've been here for lunch a few times;the price is right, I...More

Date of visit: October 2016
Thank lifoodie2017
Reviewed January 18, 2017

Had lunch here the other day and it was the best fish we had in years. We both had something different and shared half of each, one was Tuna sandwich & other was Lobster Roll. It was excellent, big chucks of lobster on the roll,...More

Date of visit: January 2017
Thank NYGeorgiaJim
Reviewed November 8, 2016

We've lived in the Sayville area for about two years and had been buying our fish at the front of the Fish Store when we realized there was a little restaurant in the back. It is very unpretentious and the waitresses may need a bit...More

Date of visit: October 2016
Thank Katskillkid
Reviewed October 12, 2016 via mobile

This is by far the best little seafood restaurant in the area. I always am so pleased with anything that I get there. The fish is always fresh and cooked just right. The clams and oysters were the best I've had all season. The decor...More

Date of visit: October 2016
Thank 730francesab
View more reviews
Nearby HotelsSee all nearby hotels
Land's End Motel
19 reviews
1.86 miles away
La Quinta by Wyndham Islip - MacArthur Airport
783 reviews
3.23 miles away
Clarion Hotel & Conference Center
298 reviews
4.07 miles away
Hilton Garden Inn Islip/MacArthur Airport
1,100 reviews
4.69 miles away
Nearby RestaurantsSee all 23 nearby restaurants
Grey Horse Tavern
101 reviews
.07 miles away
Le Soir
75 reviews
.03 miles away
Satellite Pizza
51 reviews
.08 miles away
Nearby AttractionsSee all 2 nearby attractions
Country Junque
11 reviews
.60 miles away
Corey Beach
25 reviews
1.23 miles away
Saiville Ferry Service
7 reviews
1.74 miles away
Fire Island National Seashore
181 reviews
1.84 miles away
Questions & Answers
Get quick answers from The Fish Store staff and past visitors.
Note: your question will be posted publicly on the Questions & Answers page.
Posting guidelines
Is This Your Listing?
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.
Claim Your Free Listing