Disappointing - hard to say which was worse - the dry bakery items or the surly girl working behind the counter.
1 - 10 of 12 reviews
I needed a German Chocolate Cake for a birthday and this bakery delivered. I called on Saturday and spoke to Kathy and she promised to bake one fresh for me on Sunday which she did. When I picked up the cake had to try some...More
I've come in several times since moving into the neighborhood a couple of months ago. I love old school bakeries and am especially fond of good apple strudel which this place claims to be famous for. Unfortunately, the strudel is sad ... the apple/cinnamon filling...More
They have been a fixture in town for over 100 years. Everything is baked in a brick oven. I love the Apple Strudel, and around the holidays the family looks forward to my bringing the Apple/Cranberry Strudel. Their cakes, pies and tarts are all delicious...More
The best bakery in town! Varrelmann's has been a part of the fabric of Rutherford's downtown for decades and it never fails to disappoint. I stop by every morning to get a cup of freshly brewed coffee and a buttered roll. Every once in a...More
Recently I visited and needed to get a cake for lunch at a friend's house. The attendant noticed I could not make up my mind and asked me a few questions about the occasion and suggested the seasonal peach cake/tart. I was hesitant because I...More
Varrelmann's has been in town for decades. They have some excellent baked goods but the variety is limited. Also, sometimes the cakes are not fresh. I love their 7-layer cake. The owners care and are an important part of our downtown.
In this day and age of franchise and central factories making and distributing this is a throw back. You walk in and the smell of the oven presenting daily fresh made desserts from around the globe. Simply the best apple turnover around. They are famous...More