AMAZING FOOD and everyone was SO friendly. I enjoyed the environment and vibe of the restaurant. Would definitely go back!

Nice little train station café. I stopped by for lunch and ordered the “Sloppy” to go. It turned out to be the largest and most filled Sloppy I have had. The turkey & ham were fresh sliced and it even had strips of bacon giving...it that extra flavor. I really liked it.More

Came for dinner, thank god I checked their hours. They close at 830 during the week. Definitely a coffee shop vibe. Had the hot roast beef sandwich, very tasty. My friend had the turkey club which she said was also tasty. We shared a piece...of blueberry pie. I’ve had better. Very reasonable prices. Not the most friendliest service. Would come back.More

I really wanted to like the Butler's Pantry Trackside. Though it is most certainly not a bad place to eat, I can't rate it higher than I did. I wish there would be a Tripadvisor rating between Average, which has a negative connotation, and Very...Good, but since there isn't, its shortcomings prevent me from taking that rather large step to Very Good. This is a converted train station (and I like the idea of repurposing buildings such as this that have a certain charm) with perhaps a dozen tables. The menu offerings are a combination of the usual luncheonette fare (soups, salads, sandwiches, breakfast until 11:30) with some house specials. The food is not bad, though it does not rise to the level of Very Good in my opinion. On the occasions I have been there, only one waitress was taking care of all the tables which was a bit inefficient. If you are in the area and want a bite to eat locally, I would not try to dissuade you from giving the Butler's Pantry Trackside a try, but perhaps with tempered expectations.More

The waitress is all business. No trivial banter, no friendly greeting, unless you consider "Coffee?" a friendly greeting, which I'm more or less inclined to do. We got there at 9:30 AM, well after the frantic wave of commuters had settled into the trains and...been whisked away. The mood was desultory, calm, and a bit subdued. Trains still came and went but no one left the restaurant or entered it when they did. It was a moody, tranquil place. Edward Hopper would have loved it here. Service was OK. Food was simple breakfast fare, but well prepared and quite tasty. Coffee was so-so, which is a bit surprising in an upscale place like Far Hills. I expected better. If I lived here, though, I'd be a regular. If I ever pass through Far Hills again, this is where I'd stop.More

The best turkey club sandwich I've ever had. I've been to this small, at no-frills café restaurant inside of what used to be the Far Hills train station ticket office. The restaurant has a surprisingly extensive menu, but I keep ordering the same thing which...is a delicious turkey club on toasted white bread, served with a pickle spear and potato chips. There is never more than one server for the whole room, so the service is not terribly fast... so don't be in a hurry. I believe they also offer takeout service. It's a great place to meet friends and relax and have a nice meal. It's definitely a well-kept secret by the locals because often I see people in equestrian riding gear in there. Since this is a working train station, make sure you park in the spots along side the restaurant that are clearly marked. Enjoy!More

Pleasant surprise. Met friends who had been there before. Selected prime rib special. Reasonably priced and tasty. Will go back