Grew up in Belmar. Now living in St Louis, where they have no clue about good pizza. It was ok, but not really great.
1 - 10 of 113 reviews
Federico's has alot to offer. If you like the NY style pizza this place is for you. Very diverse menu with ample daily specials. If casual family dining is what you're looking for, this place has plenty of seating both inside and out. Portions are...More
Friendly.efficient service. delish pizza, very big portions. Ceasar salad was enough for 2 people. personal pizza enough for 2
We’ve eaten there several times and have not been disappointed. The pizza is awesome! We also had a family meal and everything came out terrific. This is one of our go to places when we hit the Jersey Shore.
Nice family style pizzaria where many go for lunch, business and for pleasure. Friendly atmosphere, priced right. Best pizza in the area if you like thin crust, not buried in cheese with tasty sauce that is not sweet. (Although some may argue Vic's in Bradley...More
I stopped by after a day at the beach to have their pizza and wasn't really impressed. The cheese was falling apart as I tried to eat a slice and the pie itself wasn't anything crazy. Most people I know have had a better experience...More
For our last night in Belmar, we decided to try local pizza. Federico's was recommended by a lady on the beach. We liked that it was within walking distance of our Airbnb. It was byob and had a nice, low-key atmosphere with both indoor and...More
Eggplant Parm, side of pasta with sauce, and Special Lasagna all very salty, almost inedible. In addition, eggplant parm was mushy and soggy, clearly made well in advance, including strip of plastic wrap melted on side oven proof dish. Very disappointed. Service was nice, room...More
Plain thin crust is on point! Wife had a specialty slice, she didn't love it as much as I did. Can't comment on rest of menu but I'll be back for sure when we are in this location. Great for families or small groups.