This was my first experience at a Casey's, since we do not have them in Georgia; I was visiting La Plata for the annual La Plata Rail Days event. I'd been told that I should definitely try Casey's pizza while visiting, so I did. My...first experience, with a plain-cheese slice from the rotating carousel, was only so-so, but later I split a barbecue-chicken pizza with a friend and it was quite good -- surprisingly good for an eatery in a convenience store! I went there one more time before I left, but when I went to the order counter, the store manager told me that their food-service employee was working alone and it would be a long time before he could get to me. My suggestion would be to hire at least one more food-service/prep employee at this location. There is clearly enough pizza/sub sandwich business (received by phone as well as in-store) to support hiring another employee, and it would reduce wait times considerably.More

With no restaurants of our desire (can't eat Mexican), we had read good reviews of the nearby Casey's. we were staying at Depot Inn. There were no pizza slices at all, there was no one at the counter to make a sandwich, so had to...wait and wait, was told he was 'busy'. That was an ok sandwich at least. Also no hot sandwiches (tenderloins/chicken), no tator wedges/chicken strips etc, NOTHING! We did get salads that had been made in the cooler, lacked ingredients, was mostly nothing but hunks of lettuce.(tops were deceiving!). Disappointed. was looking forward to slices of pizza.More

Casey’s was recommended to me by others who had visited La Plata; and I have to say they were right! There’s just something about eating tasty Casey’s pizza and enjoy a coke while hanging out at the lookout or the train station watching all the...trains pass. Casey’s pizza is great railfanning foodMore

The next-door Mexican restaurant had been closed since Christmas. Darn. But, a good alternative was the great foot-long turkey-cheese sub from Caseys. Ate it at the Amtrak station. Fun time.

ONLY REGULAR GAS available plus diesel. Limited snack selection. The pizzas look good and handmade on site.

We stopped in several times while staying at Depot Inn to get drinks, snacks, pizza and sandwiches. Store is very clean and the employees are great. My son loved the pizza. I had a couple of different sandwiches that were good.

Casey's always has hot fresh excellent pizza! Used them for a family get together and were pleased with six hot fresh pizza's we purchased!

For being a kitchen in a gas station, Casey's is a hidden gem! Their BBQ Beef, Cheeseburger and Taco pizzas are DELICIOUS!!

This Casey's store has always been neat and clean and the pizza is great! They usually offer some good specials as well. Will definitely be ordering pizza from here again.

The taco pizza is amazing!! It was fast and friendly and well priced. Caseys pizza is the best pizza ever!!!

Pizza was good. Really only place open when we arrived in town so it was nice it was available. Wings were just okay.

I was very skeptical when my husband recommended late night pizza from a general store/ gas station while we were staying at a hotel, but I was very pleasantly surprised. Made to order. Yummy, better than the some pizza joints.