I called and ordered a few pies ahead of time. They were fresh out of the oven when I arrived. The pies we got were $18 each which seems pricey but they are amazing. We got a couple cherry pies and an apple caramel pecan...pie. You won’t be disappointed!More
Thank you for taking the time to leave a 5 star review. So happy to hear that you enjoyed our pies!
We live in the area and have been to 5 or 6 different locations. All have a high standard of cleanliness and excellent food. The Coconut Cream Pie is the standard by which all other Coconut Pies are judged! Unfortunately this particular location gets a...FAIL. We normally eat at the WEST Front Street location but have twice tried this location, once was earlier this summer and again this Halloween. The Coconut Cream Pie was substandard. Mealy and not as flavorful. Really a huge disappointment when compared to the normal top quality we receive at the other location. We did not post a negative review the first time but now that we have had two in a row........ Such a bummer. Still gets a two for cleanliness and friendly, knowledgable staff.More
Hi Pumpkin, thank you so much for taking the time to leave us a review. We truly appreciate your feedback and I will be sure to pass this along to our team so we can check our recipe and process. We'd love to have the...More
We never fail to get a pie (or 2) when visiting Traverse City. They have the best crusts and fillings of any pie anywhere! We also took a muffin and apple pastry. Everything they sell is of the highest quality.
Thank you so much for the wonderful 5 stars, St. Nick! We are so pleased to hear that you enjoy our shop and especially our handmade pies, muffins, and pastries. We hope to see you again soon.
Great menus. Breakfast wraps, egg soufflés , sandwiches & salads. Wonderful pies, apple dumplings. Will not be disappointed. Food is delicious
Thank you so much for your wonderful review, Kathy! We love to hear that you enjoy our shop. :) We hope to see you again soon!
This place just reopened a month ago. They make a real effort with Covid. They all wear masks, are socially distant and even the soft drink machine is closed. Good was good as usual. Service was fine. They really make an effort and it shows....They made us all wear masks when we entered.More
Thank you very much for visiting us and for taking the time to leave a review, Nardiesally! We are happy to hear you enjoyed your recent visit and appreciated the extra safety precautions we have in place. :) We hope to see you again soon!
Cashier had major attitude. They were out of many things so I ordered a peanut butter cup. It was hard, dry and crumbly. Didn’t like it. The muffin was just ok. Blt was ok. Blueberry applesauce was good. Just guessing but I’m sure there are...better optionsMore
Hi Kelly, thank you so much for visiting us and especially for taking the time to let us know about your experience. I'm so sorry to hear about your disappointing visit to our Downtown Traverse City shop. I'd love to have our General Manager give...More
Love the selection of pies - especially love the crumb topping ones. Love the peanut butter cup cookie/cupcake. They are fair priced.
Thank you very much for your wonderful review! We are so pleased to hear that you enjoy our handmade pies and baked goods. We appreciate your review and we hope to see you again soon!
Great stop on Front Street in Traverse City. They're known for their pies which are great. If you can't make up your mind, get the ABC pie. It's 1/3 apple, 1/3 blueberry and 1/3 cherry. They have small pies and other baked goods. Their soups...and sandwiches are great. Definitely a great breakfast, lunch and casual dinner spot. I ran in and bought a pie for us this afternoon. I purchase the ABC pie for new neighbors or , if we need to take something to a dinner.More
Thank you so much for your kind words and for sharing our pies with your friends and neighbors! We love to hear that you enjoy our Michigan ABC Pie so much and our handmade pies in general. We hope to see you again soon. :)
We have been long time customers. As all the real restaurants were busy with the Saturday night crowd we decided to try the GT Pie Company to see if we could get in. They were not at all busy. That should have been a clue....We waited quite a while to get waited on which seemed odd as there were not many customers. My wife ordered her usual French Dip and I the Chicken Pot Pie which has always been good. First problem was those two items with water was just over $18.00. While waiting I discovered I could have had the same meal with a salad and a piece of pie for just a few cents more. When I mentioned it the lady told me that was a good deal. OK so she had my money, that was my fault. I should have read the specials. To be fair she did give us two pie tickets. When the food came my wife's sandwich was warm at best. I started on the pot pie. I learned that chicken and vegetables are not required, the meal was so salty I had to stop eating it. On top of that it was nearly all gravy with very (did I say very? I meant near none.) few vegetables and not one detectable hint of chicken,,, with very salty gravy. On the upside the crust was flaky ... On the down side I developed such a case of indigestion we had to go home. We always loved this place and we were saddened to see the place think that it was a good idea to serve this kind of meal. Too many great restaurants in TC. No intention of returning and wasting my money.More
Hi Michael, thank you very much for visiting us and for taking the time to leave a review. However, I'm so sorry to hear about your disappointing pot pie. :( This is definitely not typical of our pot pies and we would love to have...More
What, out of your specialty and no more today? They did offer to call their other outlet on the other side of town to see if they had any, and I could walk in the cold and rain way over there to have some. Disappointing.More
Hi Milton, thank you very much for visiting us and for taking the time to write a review. I'm so sorry to hear that we were out of Chicken Pot Pie during your visit. We try our best to predict demand each day and sometimes,...More
We were give a gift card to use here while visiting Traverse City. When we arrived we had a hard time choosing, but got a small cherry pie to take to our cottage. We also enjoyed muffins and coffee while there. The pie was excellent...- perfect amount of tartness. The muffins and coffee's were also very good!More
Thank you very much for your wonderful 5-star review, Maribeth! We absolutely love to hear that you enjoyed your cherry pie as well as your muffins and coffee during your visit. We appreciate your kind words and we hope to see you again next time...More
My husband and I stopped in on our visit to downtown Traverse City. We ordered our lunch at the counter and then our name was called and we went to the pick up area to get our food, which came out very quickly. We both...had a piece of quiche and a salad with cherries in it.....both were excellent and moderately priced!! The restaurant and restrooms were clean. We would go back again! Next time we will buy one of their many pies!!More
Thank you so much to you and your husband for visiting us, lamp2660. We love to hear that you both enjoyed your slices of quiche and your salads. We appreciate your review and we hope to see you next time you're in Traverse City or...More
We stopped in here for dessert specifically because my husband wanted to try the Vernor's Cherry Pie. I love that it's in the downtown and walking distance from the shops. We went in and waited a bit in line (it was mid-afternoon) and got our...mini pies. We ended up getting a mini Vernor's Cherry and a mini Apple with Pecan & Caramel. Both were good. You can really taste the Vernor's in the pie so if you love Vernor's, you'll be a fan of this flavor. I wish the line and set up moved a bit better, though. The registers are right next to each other so it gets a little congested when two groups are ordering. Plus people are picking up their food. That aside, the food is always great. We eat at Grand Traverse Pie Co when we want to eat out but not have fast food.More
Thank you so much for your review, JAR. We are so happy to hear that you and your husband enjoyed your visit and especially your Apple Pie and Vernors Cherry Pie. We appreciate your feedback on our line and ordering system as well. Thanks again...More
We ate here for lunch on a Monday and they were really busy! Good sign except it was only noon and they had no quiche! None of any kind,how strange is that ? So I got a beef pasty and Vernors cherry pie slice. Hubby...got a sandwich and cherry crumb pie. My pasty was okay. I prefered the cherry crumb over the Vernor's cherry. It is a good value. Would try again when they are well stocked on quiche! LolMore
Hi Kami, thank you so much to you and your husband for giving us a chance. While I'm sorry we were out of quiche during your visit, I'm happy to hear you enjoyed your meals. We thank you for taking the time to let us...More
My 11 year old loves the Apple Pastry Pie the best. There is many delicious pies to choose from and great coffee as well. Service is very friendly and fast.
Thank you very much for your wonderful review, Mimi. We love to hear that you and your daughter enjoy our shop and especially our Apple Pastry Pie and our friendly service. We hope to see you both again soon!