Stopped in for a beer on our way to the lighthouse and thoughrly enjoyed it! The bar where the actual murder took place in the famous novel and movie “Anatomy of a Murder” lots of pictures and memorabilia to look at and if you sit...at the bar as we did, ask to see the scrapbook of actual pictures of the body of the victim and the murder suspect. He makes a really good garlic breadsticks too! Fun place!More

Fascinating little bar in a town that time may have forgotten. It was the site of a murder borne of passion and the source of an academy award winning movie, “Anatomy of a Murder”. The bar has a good choice of beers, but the wine...hides in a box that has never seen a refrigerator. The bread sticks are excellent. The bar has a stylized outline of a body still on the time-worn floor, and a notebook full of original clippings, autopsy photos, and first-person interviews. It is well worth a drink and will provide memories for conversation for years to come.More

This place is a must see. It’s the actual location of the film “anatomy of a murder”. Lots of cool stuff to look at. Our barmaid, Jill was so friendly. The deliciousness of the house made, bread and all, cheese garlic bread was something I...couldn’t even imagine existed.More

Great homemade crust and breadsticks. Great pizza. Friendly people. The movie history is a fun bonus.

Seems like just a bar. Some interesting old things hanging from the ceiling. Lots of wood everywhere. Has a history associated with the movie "Anatomy of a Murder". Don't need to go back.

If you like vintage things to look at and read about, this is the place to stop. Nice people and an old time feel.

Had a great stay in Big Bay. One of our stops was the Lumberjack Tavern, scene of the bartenders murder back in the 50s story behind the movie "Anatomy of a Murder". Worth the visit, decent burgers, nice selection of craft beers, interesting place.