We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
I love ice cream. I eat it every day! This place was recommended in the tour books but we were not impressed at all. I don't think I have ever returned ice cream but I did here. I ordered the coconut ice cream and it...tasted awful. I went back to the counter to tell them. I did allow me to get a different flavor instead. I chose mint chocolate chip which was good but not any better than anywhere else. It was nice of them to allow me to change my flavor choice though.More
Came here many times over the years. They used to have many, many flavors. I was disappointed when we visited this past summer. Their flavors were limited and they offered no sugar free ice cream. The lines used to be very long but no wait...when we visited.More
Mad Martha's is an absolutely excellent ice cream parlor that anyone will truly appreciate! They serve the best ice cream on the island by far! It is especially enjoyable for all new visitors to the island and I strongly recommend it!
At Mad Martha's you can get two scoops (cup or bowl) for very little more than one scoop; I usually prefer a cone over a bowl, but I would recommend (if you are a couple looking for ice cream) getting a bowl with 2 scoops...rather than each getting a 1 scoop cone or bowl. Lots of interesting sundae choices and many good flavors to choose from. Cash only.More
My friends loved their flavors but I had the snickers ice cream and though I sampled it, as I dug into the cup it was waaaay too sweet. A small cup was $4.95 but it was so sweet that I had to throw it away....Shucks!More
Actually, I only get one flavor here which is pistachio. I love pistachio because it’s not green colored and they put plenty of nuts in the ice cream. If you’re not a pistachio fan I can’t help you with the other flavors
The girls brought back some of MM ice cream while us guys were watching MNF . Very good... I received the peanut butter cup.. VG and my buddies got Strawberry (excellent!) and Chocolate VG too! It was all good!