Friendly and caring staff, very good food, nicely situated in the harbor with excellent view over the harbor activity when on the patio.
Is this restaurant good for special occasions?
Is this restaurant good for brunch?
Is this restaurant good for large groups?
Is this restaurant good for business meetings?
Does this restaurant offer takeout or food to go?
Does this restaurant have parking?
Does this restaurant serve dinner?
Does this restaurant serve lunch?
Is this restaurant wheelchair accessible?
Does this restaurant serve breakfast?
Thanks for helping!Share another experience before you go.
My family visits the Vineyard every year, and we've been going to the Atlantic since it opened. We've always had mixed feelings because while it's lovely to sit on the porch or deck with a close view of the boats in the harbor, the food and drinks are very expensive and food and service have been inconsistent and terrible at... More
Returned here after a few wonderful experiences in early June. This time, sat on deck facing the harbor, wonderful view. However we waited a very long time for drinks. That paled in comparison to this: my husband ordered a Macallan 12 year old scotch. He knows this product, and had had some from our stock recently. The drink served to... More
I had dinner with some of the girls and everything was delicious! I had the swordfish, not as large a portion as I would have hoped for. One of the girls had the mussels and tuna which she raved about. The watermelon and feta salad was very tasty. The service was outstanding! We will definitely go back..
Had lunch there. Sat outdoors facing harbor - very scenic. Food was average, service was slow. Since there are so msny other choices in Edgartown, we wouldn't return
My husband & I visited Atlantic on the recommendation of the hotel concierge during our short get away to Martha's Vineyard. Not only was the atmosphere amazing but the food was spectacular! Dare I say one of the best meals I've had In the last couple of years. There were so many of our favorite dishes on the menu we... More
I'm a 20 plus year summer resident of the Vineyard. Last Wednesday we headed over to The Atlantic to meet some friends for drinks. When we arrived the doorman and bouncer had velvet ropes set up by the door and there was a small line. They were very slowly checking ID's and every couple of minutes would let a few... More
Watching small and large ships as we enjoyed fresh seafood and desserts of hudge portions helped make our first visit to the island outstanding fun.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.Claim Your Listing