We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

Ratings and reviews

RATINGS
Food
Service
Value

Details

CUISINES
Pizza, Italian
Special Diets
Vegetarian Friendly
Meals
Lunch, Dinner
View all details
meals, features
Reviews (37)
Filter reviews
37 results
Traveler rating
23
5
5
1
3
Traveler type
Time of year
LanguageEnglish
Traveler rating
23
5
5
1
3
Show reviews that mention
All reviews ny pizza salad garlic knots are slice crust cheese ky
Selected filters
FilterEnglish
Updating list...
Reviewed December 8, 2020 via mobile

I went to the restaurant on Factory Lane off LaGrange Road. I was beyond disappointed. I wish I had taken a picture. I ordered two medium pizzas and tipped generously. My total came to $48.00. When I got home and opened the boxes, the pizzas...looked pitiful. One of the pizzas was completely thrown in the box. The pizzas were dry and tasteless. The pizzas in the Walmart deli are 10 times better than this. Honestly, Frozen pizza is better. The restaurant itself leaves a lot to be desired. I should have known by the piled up pizza boxes that my expectations were way too high. I won’t be back!More

Date of visit: December 2020
Helpful?1  
Reviewed December 4, 2020 via mobile

I tried Old New York Pizza tonight. I ordered one cheese pizza $16.04, one Whitestone $17.95 and one make your own with an assortment of four toppings $21.67. I ordered from their web site which was slightly antiquated and took a bit of time. I...set up an account in hopes I had found a great new pizza discovery. They have no delivery unfortunately, so I selected carry out. I tipped on the app and it said to pick up the pizza in 60 minutes. I went there in 40 wanting to make sure my pizza was hot and fresh. Upon entering the dining room, there was a mountain of folded in a boxed sitting on the table in the foyer. I thought that seemed a little strange that anyone could have access to touching any of these boxes or coughing or whatever. There were at least 100 of them sitting there. The person at the register asked my name and then walked around the counter to a delivery bag sitting on another fold up table. My order was already made and sitting in the bag despite arriving 20 minutes sooner. I also ordered a large Greek salad to share. When I got home 10 minutes away, I opened all boxes for our group to eat. I noticed the pizza was slightly cold already. There was definitely no oozy cheese anywhere. It was too cold and very flat. The pizza was missing any kind of salt or basil which might give it some flavor. I realized they did not ask me if I’d like Parmesan or red pepper. My bad. I wished I had gotten some to add to the flavor. The Whitestone though was unlike any white pizza I’ve ever had. It was supposed to have a ricotta spread, herbs, Romano cheese and garlic oil. It literally was tasteless, an inedible pizza truly. The universal feeling Of anyone who tried it was it was just bad. I rarely will call on pizza but I thought the owner would like to know if a pizza came out that dry and tasteless. Boy, I was in for a surprise. I spoke to the person answering the phone who passed along the phone to an older man. I explained the pizza’s dryness. He said “that is how it is made. He said you dont like it, that is your fault. You dont get nothing. This is how it is made.” Not only is this called Old New York Style pizza. It is a rude New York style attitude. He can take his dried up, card board pizza and stick it. I would never walk foot into this ridiculous establishment with this mean old owner. I wish I could have taken my $10 tip back from someone who certainly did not deserve it. For $80 plus dollars, you can certainly find much better.More

Date of visit: December 2020
Helpful?1  
Reviewed November 1, 2020 via mobile

Best pizza in KY-felt like we were on Staten Island! Great salad, good wine and fabulous service (Stephanie).

Date of visit: November 2020
Helpful?1  
Reviewed September 12, 2020 via mobile

I stopped by to try our new Norton Commons Pizza place! I am from Long Island NY! I purchased slice. Size of slice is smaller than NY! A slice of pizza in Ny averages $2.50 a slice! This restaurant charges $4.00 a slice! A bit...over the top price per size. It was adequate as far as crust/pepperoni and taste!More

Date of visit: September 2020
Helpful?
Reviewed September 9, 2020

Hostess could not answer any basic menu questions NOR the server. We ordered by the slice pizza to start plus drinks. The server brought the drinks then our food AND the check at the same time. We PLANNED to order more but felt rushed as...if she wished to move on to the next tip. The pizza slices were obviously not fresh. Re-heated Dominos at midnight is better. We were glad Bruscos moved on because the service was terrible but their by the slice was AMAZING. Please pay them for their recipe! We support our local businesses. We want them to be successful. But please train your staff! Even the greeter was not friendly at all. I was mid sentence as she simply walked away. Hoping for the best but not holding my breath after today.More

Date of visit: September 2020
Helpful?2  
Reviewed March 8, 2020 via mobile

The staff is very gracious and efficient. The food is spot on. Being from NYC the cheese pie felt like being at home. The garlic knots are actually better than the pizza joint I've been going to for over 40 years in NY. Definitely recommend...dining at this great find.More

Date of visit: February 2020
Helpful?
Reviewed January 26, 2020 via mobile

I placed a 2-go order. The person on the phone wasn’t very informative with my couple questions. The pizza was ok just expected more with the name of the place. “NY” pizza company.

Date of visit: January 2020
Helpful?
Reviewed January 5, 2020

We Love the Pizza and the slice size. New York style. Very friendly staff Real feel of a pizza place

Date of visit: January 2020
Helpful?
Reviewed January 3, 2020 via mobile

This place is awesome. Pizza is top notch and worth the price. I wouldn't say I am a pizza snob but I lived in the Philly South Jersey area and I've been exposed to some good pizza. The pizza is just like that! Crust is...amazing and made fresh in house. You can order a counter pie which let's you pick a d choose from a bunch of different toppings but still gets you a whole pizza for the same price. BBQ chicken and buffalo chicken were amazing. I will be back for more next time I am in town. Currently they are working on expanding to have a bar section with TVs. I am excited for next time I come back and it be finished!More

Date of visit: January 2020
Helpful?
Reviewed August 12, 2019 via mobile

Pizza is fine, but no better than fine. A little too tomato-ey for my taste. Soda refills are always good but the root beer was out, which was a shame. Staff are friendly and efficient.

Date of visit: August 2019
Helpful?
View more reviews
Best nearby
Best nearby hotelsSee all
Residence Inn Louisville Old Henry
2 reviews
1.25 miles away
La Quinta Inn & Suites by Wyndham Louisville East
1 review
1.54 miles away
Holiday Inn Express Louisville Northeast
169 reviews
2.12 miles away
Hampton Inn Louisville-Northeast
631 reviews
2.20 miles away
Best nearby restaurantsSee all
Brix Wine Bar & Bistro
52 reviews
.17 miles away
El Nopal
10 reviews
.17 miles away
Mi Tierra Mexican Restaurant
7 reviews
.14 miles away
Best nearby attractionsSee all
Kentucky Artisan Distillery
229 reviews
4.23 miles away
Openrange
39 reviews
4.20 miles away
EP "Tom" Sawyer State Park
23 reviews
2.45 miles away
Middletown Peddlers Mall
18 reviews
2.97 miles away
Questions & Answers
Get quick answers from Old School Ny Pizza staff and past visitors.
Note: your question will be posted publicly on the Questions & Answers page.
Submit
Posting guidelines
Is This Your Listing?
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.
Claim Your Free Listing
Frequently Asked Questions about Old School Ny Pizza

  • Yes, Old School Ny Pizza offers takeout services.

  • Yes, Old School Ny Pizza offers delivery services.

  • Old School Ny Pizza is rated accordingly in the following categories by Tripadvisor travelers:
    • Food: 4.5
    • Service: 4.5
    • Value: 4.5