We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

Fat Jimmy's Middletown

Ratings and reviews



Pizza, Italian
Lunch, Dinner
Takeout, Seating, Wheelchair Accessible
View all details
features, about


All Day Buffet!!!
Drink Included.
Kids 4-12
Drink included.
Kids 3 and under
Hot Buttery Balls
Baked pieces of dough covered with garlic sauce, parmesan and oregano. Served with pizza sauce
Garlic Bread
Hoagie roll toasted with garlic sauce and oregano. Served with pizza sauce
Cheese Bread
Hoagie roll baked with mozzarella / provolone cheese and oregano. Served with pizza sauce
Pizza Bread
Baked hoagie roll with pizza sauce, cheese, pepperoni and oregano
All of our salads are made with romaine lettuce and served with the dressing on the side. Ask for our dressing selection. Add a side salad to any entree for only $2.50
Onion, green pepper, mushroom & tomato
All the veggies of the garden salad with pepperoni, ham, turkey, cheese and bacon
Grilled Chicken
Our garden salad with chicken and bacon
Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce with parmesan & croutons
Side Salad
Lettuce, cheese and tomato
$7.25 Each. All subs are baked on an 8" hoagie roll and served with your choice of chips or a side salad. Feel free to hold and add ingredients to make it yours. Make it a Wrap
Santa Fe Sub
Ranch, chicken, cheese, onion, lettuce & tomato
BBQ Chicken
BBQ sauce, chicken, cheese, onion, lettuce & tomato
Fat Jimmy Club
Ranch, ham, turkey, cheese, onion, lettuce & tomato
Stromboli Sub
Pizza sauce, sausage, beef, pepperoni, onion, green pepper, cheese & oregano
Ranch, bacon, cheese, lettuce & tomato
Pizza sauce, meatballs, onion, green pepper & cheese
Hot Italian
Italian dressing, ham, salami, pepperoni, cheese, onion, lettuce & tomato
Veggie Sub
Ranch, mushroom, green pepper, onion, lettuce & tomato
Choose any 3 toppings from our pizza menu
Made with a blend of ricotta, mozzarella and provolone cheese. Served with pizza sauce. Add toppings for $1 each
All of our pastas are baked with penne pasta and a blend of mozzarella and provolone cheese. Served with garlic bread
Red Sauce Pasta
Marinara, cheese and oregano
Meat Sauce
Pepperoni, sausage and beef
Meatball Pasta
Meatballs, green pepper & onion
Cheesy Alfredo
Chicken Alfredo
Coke Products
Fountain Drinks
20 Oz. Bottle
Fresh Brewed Tea
2 Liter Drink
Sweet Balls by the Dozen
3 For $1.25
Dozen $4.25
Chocolate Chip Cookies
6" One Topping Pizza
Baked Cheese Sandwich
Turkey and Cheese Sandwich
Ham and Cheese Sandwich
Butter Noodles
Noodles with Red Sauce
Our party platters feed 8 - 10 people. Plates, forks and napkins are available upon request
Italian, Caesar or Pasta Salad
Cheesy Red Pasta
Cheesy Meat Pasta
Alfredo Pasta
Chicken Alfredo
Whole Wheat Wrap Tray
Reviews (20)
Filter reviews
20 results
Traveler rating
Traveler type
Time of year
See what travelers are saying:
Updating list...
1 - 10 of 20 reviews
Reviewed September 10, 2018

We love pizza and heard this was one of the better ones in the area so we thought we would give them a try. The soup tonight was Taco and was delicious. I was surprised when I found out it was homemade. It was so...More

Date of visit: September 2018
Thank Richard F
Reviewed February 26, 2018 via mobile

My family and I recently tried Fat Jimmys. We are from out of town so we had not even heard of it before, but I am glad we found it! There were eight of us and the staff was helpful in pushing together some tables....More

Date of visit: February 2018
Thank stellaropal
Reviewed January 20, 2018 via mobile

We love eating at Fat Jimmys. We normally get the buffet. He is always prompt at getting the food out if it's getting low. I would recommend going if you're looking for a family friendly pizza restaurant.

Date of visit: November 2017
Thank LaLO929
Reviewed September 7, 2017 via mobile

The pizza buffet is very good and the calzones are full of flavor! The staff is always super friendly when we visit! Good place to take the kids as well!

Date of visit: July 2017
Thank bluesmom98
Reviewed May 24, 2017 via mobile

This is the best bacon chicken ranch pizza in town! My family devours this pizza. Staff is super friendly and the buffet is a great deal. Kids eat the buffet on Monday & Tuesday nights for $2!!!! This place is a definite go to for...More

Date of visit: May 2017
Thank hollydee73
Reviewed April 26, 2017

If you haven't been to Fat Jimmy's, you're missing out. The guys making the pizzas ad working the counter are the friendliest bunch of pizza slingers I've ever met. The selection is good and fresh hot pizzas are always coming out to the buffet bar....More

Date of visit: January 2017
Thank Lori M
Reviewed February 15, 2017 via mobile

Great pizza, great value and great service. Locally owned, kid friendly and buffet option. Love coming here for kids sports team parties.

Date of visit: February 2017
Thank swoony11
Reviewed November 27, 2016 via mobile

Buffalo Chicken Bacon Pizza Best in town. Employees friendly. Family atmosphere. Buffet was clean and good selection. Would like to of seen a thin crust as one of the options. Good stop!

Date of visit: November 2016
Thank 604kenf
Reviewed November 22, 2016

Pizza Buffet is great and alwatpys fresh! Lots of choices! Menu choices are great as well! Excellent Calzones!

Date of visit: November 2016
Thank bluesmom98
Reviewed November 13, 2016 via mobile

Great food, friendly people, fantastic prices ! We love this place. Can we get the chocolate chip cookie recipe ?

Date of visit: November 2016
Thank Kella S
View more reviews
Questions & Answers
Get quick answers from Fat Jimmy's Middletown staff and past visitors.
Note: your question will be posted publicly on the Questions & Answers page.
Posting guidelines
Is This Your TripAdvisor Listing?
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more. Claim Your Listing