Updating Map... 1 - 10 of 172 reviews
Went for dinner with a family party of 7 while staying in Lexington on our way south for a family vacation. Walked in about 7:30pm, we were seated within 5 min. Apps came out quick and were great, kids meals came out, then we heard...More
We are so happy that you enjoyed your visit at our small family Italian restaurant! Thank you for taking the time to tell other Travellers about your experience and mentioning some of our specific items that you were pleased to enjoy from the menu. Thank...More
I had the Hot Sicilian sub and my husband had the flat iron steak. Server was great and food was delicious. We will definitely visit again.
Thank you very much for taking the time from your busy schedule to send us this fantastic review! I am very happy you enjoyed your experience. We will look forward to your return. Until then, safe travels and best regards, Gordon
A colleague and I are in town on business and looking for good Italian food. After checking reviews we decided on Sutton’s and boy are we glad! Our service was great, the food was fabulous, and the weather was gorgeous! We shared the stuffed mushrooms...More
Thank you so much for telling other Travelers about your experience in our small family restaurant! I'm so glad you were able to enjoy the weather, as we have one of the better patios in town. We hope to serve you again soon and until...More
The dinner was some of the best Italian food we have had and the server was pleasant and helpful! Try the chicken and broccoli with pasta and was delicious.More
Hello Kornelis, Thank you very much for taking the time to give us such a great review. The pasta you have recommended is one of the top selling pastas, Baked Chicken and Broccoli. Thanks for mentioning our service as well. We hope to see you...More
Came on a Sunday afternoon. With my friend around 12:30. We waited on a person to come and tell us where to sit. No hostess that day. We started with the fried banana peppers. They were rings and dipped in cocktail sauce. Very good. We...More
Thank you for providing some feedback about your visit last Sunday. I'm rather Disturbed that your experience was not better than you reported. I hope that you liked your dish with gluten-free gnocchi. We use a large 26/30 count shrimp and you should have received...More
My husband and I tried Sutton's for the first time last weekend. Our server was outstanding!! However, the meal was just ok ... not bad, but not great. There are other Italian restaurants in Lexington that we prefer so we likely won't be back.More
Very surprised to read this review. We usually exceed our guests expectations every time. My apologies for not making you a raving fan! We like to think that we serve the best Italian food in Lexington at a price everyone can afford. We hope that...More
This place has it figured out! Tonight was our first time and we most definitely will be back many more times in the future! Awesome Service with Gerald, our waiter. We tried the Sampler Appetizer (3 items, all Amazing!), We got our little girl(2yo) chicken...More
Hello Erin, Thank you for the wonderful review of some of our core menu items. We certainly appreciate that you took the time to let travelers know about our small family owned and operated business. I will be sure to thank Gerald for his service...More
My wife and I visited on Sunday night. Easy to get in, unlike the previous Friday - they were slammed! Food was so good. Every aspect was great!More
Thank you so much for taking the time to provide us with such a fantastic review! I am so glad that you decided to give us a try on Sunday. I will be sure to share your review with our staff and thank them for...More
Our server Cassidy was attentive and gave us good suggestions. The portions were large. We had mussels and calamari for appetizers. Then excellent bread with olive oil and herbs for dipping. The scallops were amazing! Chicken Parmesan was cheesy yummy goodness and a huge portion!...More
Hi Kelley, I just wanted to thank you and your family for trying our family restaurant and taking the time to write this great review. You ordered some of our most popular items! So glad that you noticed the quality and value we strive to...More
No one leaves Sutton’s without an excellent tasting meal with generous potions at a great price. This Italian restaurant is a gem. We had 2 enormous flavorful pork chops for $18 and a giant portion of delicious eggplant parmigiana for $13. We highly recommend this...More
We are so pleased that you communicate to Future Travelers and visitors our portion sizes! We truly go above and beyond to provide value for every purchase on our menu. Not only do we provide generous portions but we also purchase only the highest quality...More
