GOODFELLAS PIZZERIA - COVINGTON - Menu, Prices & Restaurant Reviews

Should have kept this place in Cincinnati. I’ve never once called and had someone answer the phone. Lmao sucks that such a good pizza spot can get ruined by trash staff.

Date of visit: November 2020

Helpful?

vickil750

1 review

Reviewed September 20, 2020

Ordered online

We were having a small engagement party in Covington and we're in from out of town. after trying to call and order pizzas for our party we were hung up on and decided to order online. Big big mistake!after placing our order online pizzas were...supposed to be ready between 6:30 and 6:40. After arrivingat 6:40 we were told our pizzas were just going in the oven period they would be another 20 minutes. So after 20 minutes we went back to the pizza shop only to find out that the pizza still were not ready.so after confronting the cashier person they didn't seem concerned and telling us that our order still was not ready. After another 15 minutes goes by we see a pizza sitting up there with our name on it.we then asked if that was all of our pizzas and they said no period but come to find out they were all done and sitting in the back. At this time it is 7:30 and we are not happy period as the engaged couple were about ready to show up at the house and we had no pizzas. Poor poor service! Uncaring service and the pizzas were lukewarm and mediocre in taste. All around horrible experience would not recommend this place!!!More

Date of visit: September 2020

Helpful?

Bernard R

1 review

Reviewed July 11, 2020 via mobile

Excellent!!

There is not enough words to describe this place!! The pizza alone was fire!! The beer selection was superb!! The alcohol selction was top notch!! Atmopshere soft grown and chill!! one can not ask for a better place while downtown cincinnati.

Date of visit: July 2020

Helpful?1

LiketoeatCincinnati

1,994 reviews

Reviewed June 13, 2020 via mobile

Pizza by the Slice

You can get good New York pizza by the slice at Goodfellas. Pizza is great and you can eat in patio out back. Definitely a must do for pizza here.

Date of visit: June 2020

Helpful?

masonmarine

220 reviews

Reviewed March 7, 2020 via mobile

Cool place in a nice area.

Cool place in a nice area. Hidden Bourbon bar upstairs. Anything you are looking for. Pizza is supposed to be good.

Date of visit: March 2020

Helpful?

Awesome! Appreciate your time leaving us a great review. Come back and try our pizza on your next visit :)

Les S

32 reviews

Reviewed March 5, 2020

We love pizza

Very interesting place,downstairs pizza by the slice or pie ,up stair bar and lounge,small,and intermittent,love seat ,armchairs,order come up from downstairs..found pizza to be very good and price reasonable.

Date of visit: February 2020

Helpful?2

Thank you for stopping by! Glad to hear you enjoyed your pizza. Come back for another slice sometime soon!

xtremes10

4 reviews

Reviewed February 18, 2020 via mobile

Amazing Pizza

What can we say? We love pizza! On our stay over the Valentine’s Day weekend on our last night my wife and I decided we wanted to have some pizza! We looked and looked but none of the reviews or pictures came close to what...we saw for Goodfellas. We originally wanted to get delivery and were a little bummed to see they didn’t deliver. We understood they want the absolute best quality possible. We grabbed an Uber and were on our way. Let me tell you, this was probably the best decision we could have made. They have a selection of pre baked pizzas in multiple flavors ready to buy by the slice or if you want a specific pizza you need to order your own. These pizzas are HUGE! I decided on two slices of pepperoni and my wife decided on a slice of cheese and a slice of pepperoni. We also ordered breadsticks and ranch as well as buffalo ranch. The pizza was absolutely exceptional, the flavors were great, the cheese and sauce were perfect and the pepperoni was so good! The breadsticks were as legit and flavorful as they come. The ranch which is house made is phenomenal but the buffalo ranch... well that was life changing. Can you just bottle it and send us some pretty please? It is absolutely worth the drive. The staff was super friendly and even jumped in on a picture for us, we truly enjoyed the decor, the atmosphere, and the food. This is the total package and the real deal. Don’t be a wise guy, forgeddabout delivery, get your butt over there and get some amazing pizza!More

Date of visit: February 2020

Helpful?

carol1631

47 reviews

Reviewed February 12, 2020 via mobile

Family Day

Pizza was really good! It was cool to be able to watch the pizza maker throw a 22” crust. There is very little seating! This is a grab & go spot unless you want to hang out in the bar upstairs. For dining in, not...family friendlyMore

Date of visit: February 2020

Helpful?

Ddeaton

50 reviews

Reviewed December 29, 2019 via mobile

Pizza and cocktails

The pizza was really good. But the best part was the cocktails upstairs. I would highly recommend the Mexican Shakedown drink! The cocktails are genuine craft cocktails!

Date of visit: December 2019

Helpful?

View more reviews

Previous Next