We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

Old Town Amish Store

COVID-19 update: See the added health and safety measures this property is taking.Read more
Travel safe during COVID-19
Visit our Travel Safe hub to see how we're helping you make more informed travel decisions during COVID-19.
What you can expect during your visit
  • Face masks required for staff in public areas
  • Hand sanitizer available to guests & staff
  • Daily temperature and symptom checks for staff
  • Socially distanced dining tables
  • Staff required to regularly wash hands
  • Tables disinfected between guests
Read more
Updated 09/12/20 Safety precautions are provided by the property and are not checked by Tripadvisor for accuracy.
A note from Old Town Amish Store
Updated 09/12/20 Safety precautions are provided by the property and are not checked by Tripadvisor for accuracy.

Ratings and reviews



$3 - $6
American, Deli, Soups
Special Diets
Vegetarian Friendly, Vegan Options, Gluten Free Options
View all details
meals, features, about
Reviews (168)
Filter reviews
167 results
Traveler rating
Traveler type
Time of year
Traveler rating
Show reviews that mention
All reviews sandwiches bread soup dry goods for sale local honey handmade items deli bulk cheese candy jams gas shopped mints peppermint exit
Selected filters
Updating list...
Reviewed August 2, 2021 via mobile

I was hesitant about going after reading some of the more recent reviews but decided why not?! I'm in the area and looks like an interesting place. I can't speak for others but my experience was good. I walked in, looked around, ordered food from...the deli, and had a wonderful conversation with the staff. Everyone was friendly and helpful. My only disappointment was I expected a bit more homemade items. There were a lot of prepackaged, mass-produced items for sale. That took away from what I expected to be mostly handcrafted woodwork and seamstress type items that I was hoping to find. The prices are reasonable and everything I bought to consume was good. Will likely visit again but it wasn't the completely unique experience I had hoped. I highlight was the peach spice cake. So yummy!More

Date of visit: August 2021
Reviewed May 6, 2021

Girl trip, we stopped in and the Staff were the rudest I have ever seen. A man behind the meat counter bit my friends head off when she pulled her mask down just a tiny bit because he couldn't hear her. She was a good...6feet away from him, plus the meat case between them, not even face level. He screamed at her to put her mask back on. She almost cried. We were very cautious because of Covid, but he was totally out of line.More

Date of visit: September 2020
Reviewed April 28, 2021

Judy Donovan whom owns the store wanted to bring love and the taste of home to the community. However, On April 27th, 2021, at approximately 3:40 PM, I witnessed a whole other side to the shop. A customer came in to shop, and the employee...immediately told the woman she had to wear a mask. The customer informed the employee that she had a health condition that prevented her from wearing a mask. As you may know there are some lung conditions that prevent people from wearing masks because a mask can be deadly to those people. The employee said the woman could not shop there without a mask. The employee was nasty about it and wouldn’t even stop stocking to speak with the woman. The woman informed the employee that wearing the mask is not a law, and she doesn’t have to with a medical condition. The employee rudely told the woman she couldn’t shop there. Now, I have done business with the Amish for many years, and the Amish do not follow the so called mask rule, and the Amish would never treat a customer like a criminal. I am curious to know how the Amish would view this situation, and I think Mrs. Donovan needs to to take the Amish name off of her business. Contempt toward a customer over a mask does not represent the views of the Amish. I was disgusted by this employees behavior and will not shop at this store ever again. If I want to shop at a true Amish store, I will drive a little out of my way to receive the kind care and assistance from real Amish folks.More

Date of visit: April 2021
old town amish store, General Manager at Old Town Amish Store, responded to this reviewResponded April 29, 2021

Ms Donovan was a beloved employee here at the Old town Amish store who decided to retire rather than possibly bring the virus home to her family. Here at our store we stay in accordance with state mandates and guide lines to keep our store...More

Reviewed March 3, 2021

We have stopped here every time we go thru the area (at least once a year). Have always enjoyed our stop and have purchased many things from the general store and have also in the past enjoyed lunch in the deli. However, today we stopped...and I was the ONLY ONE inside the store (other than employees who were back behind a counter goofing off). As I quickly walked thru the aisles and I was approaching the check out I was approached by a young man with a mask IN HIS HAND asking me to put it on as I could not be inside the store without a mask on. I explained I had a medical condition and he did not care. He wanted me to wear the mask he had in his hand (already contaminated!) NO THANKS. He told me I had to leave. I left and I won't be back. It is not going to affect his paycheck he can go back to goofing off in the back with his coworker but the owner is the one losing the business! Talk about discrimination! Teach that young man some manners and how to appropriately talk to a customer and not to handle a mask that he expects someone to wear! I don't think we will ever stop at this exit again. Very sad.More

Date of visit: February 2021
Reviewed December 31, 2020 via mobile

We had such a terrible experience. My husband and I always stop here and have lunch on our way home the food is usually good but not today. First the young gentleman working there yelled at my husband because he didn’t like the way my...husband mask fit, the pinto soup had no favor and my bread was so hard I even checked it for mold because it smelled. Won’t recommend this place no more. I should’ve asked for my money back.More

Date of visit: December 2020
Reviewed November 17, 2020

that this store sells some of the best popcorn I have ever had. Now, it is kernel popcorn, the kind you put in a pot with oil, heat up till it all (mostly all) is popped and then sit back with a good movie, a...special someone, a glass of wine and enjoy. I particularly recommend the Baby White Popcorn. This more petit size popcorn is tender & just right for munching. They do have other choices for popcorn, just can't remember them right now. But, dust off that old fashioned popcorn maker, put it to use and enjoy some really good popcorn from the Old Town Amish Store.More

Date of visit: December 2019
Reviewed October 10, 2020

They had a decent amount of dry goods for sale. We didn't eat anything here. Prices pretty decent in the store.

Date of visit: September 2020
Reviewed September 19, 2020 via mobile

We love to stop & always stock up. Tasty food, pleasant staff. If you’ve never been, you are missing out!

Date of visit: August 2020
Reviewed September 8, 2020 via mobile

I ordered a sandwich from the deli. The lady was rude and the sandwich was bad. The sandwich was soggy and bland. Worse than the food was the extremely sarcastic lady working in the deli. She made it clear she was not happy to add...mayo to my sandwich. I would not go back to this restaurant. Panera is better than this non Amish sorry excuse for a sandwich shop.More

Date of visit: September 2020
Navigator63156723611, General Manager at Old Town Amish Store, responded to this reviewResponded September 10, 2020

Hi there! Sorr;y to hear your sandwich wasn't tasty. We really love our menu and want our food to come out well. We are always happy to fix something for you if it's brought to our attention. To go sandwiches are always trickier to keep...More

Reviewed September 5, 2020 via mobile

I have never experienced worse customer service. The food was mediocre at best. This store is Amish in name only. The staff was incredibly rude and unfriendly. I would never return to this store. If you want gas station sandwiches and a hostile environment this...is the place for you!More

Date of visit: September 2020
Navigator63156723611, General Manager at Old Town Amish Store, responded to this reviewResponded September 10, 2020

Hey there! I've worked here for 8 years and have had wonderful interactions with staff. I love our employees and hear friendliness coming out of them all the time. The worldwide pandemic has indeed been the most stressful time we've ever had to experience. Trying...More

View more reviews
Best nearby
Best nearby hotelsSee all
Red Roof Inn Berea
62 reviews
.10 miles away
Holiday Motel
49 reviews
.22 miles away
Knights Inn Berea
37 reviews
.26 miles away
Fairfield Inn & Suites Lexington Berea
232 reviews
.31 miles away
Best nearby restaurantsSee all
Noodle Nirvana
104 reviews
.86 miles away
Native Bagel Company
45 reviews
.71 miles away
Cracker Barrel
170 reviews
.14 miles away
Best nearby attractionsSee all
Berea Welcome Center
132 reviews
.67 miles away
Artisan Village District
33 reviews
.68 miles away
Berea Arts Council
16 reviews
.67 miles away
Top Drawer Gallery
5 reviews
.69 miles away
Questions & Answers
Ask a question
Betty J
March 27, 2017|
AnswerShow all 6 answers
Response from Tendre P | Reviewed this property |
No way.
Is This Your Listing?
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.
Claim Your Free Listing
Frequently Asked Questions about Old Town Amish Store

Yes, Old Town Amish Store offers takeout services.

Yes, Old Town Amish Store is taking precautions against COVID-19. A full list is available within the "safety precautions" section of this page.

Old Town Amish Store is rated accordingly in the following categories by Tripadvisor travelers:
  • Food: 4
  • Service: 4
  • Value: 4
  • Atmosphere: 3.5