You will not leave hungry!! Good old fashioned home cooked food! Great staff and buffet at your table!! Didn't try anything that we didn't love!! And the peanut butter pie is to die for!!!!
251 - 260 of 1,392 reviews
This place is noted for it's fried chicken - and it is good. But this time I tried the liver and onions. If you like that you will really enjoy that here. A large serving of absolutely tender and perfectly prepared liver. And desserts are...More
Very busy restaurant on a cool Friday evening. It's first come first served...no reservations taken. We didn't have to wait at all. Our server was a pleasant young man. We had the chicken with mashed potatoes & green beans...very tasty. However, we were barely halfway...More
This restaurant has excellent home cookin', Amish style. From the bread with homemade apple butter or Amish peanut butter to salads, main courses, and desserts, the food is EXCELLENT. The staff is also helpful and kind. FYI: the broasted chicken is the best!!
My wife and I have eaten at Blue Gate Restaurant many times and this time we tried the buffet. The food is the same as the regular restaurant, which has always been very good. My water glass never went empty. Neither did my wife's coffee....More
On our recent trip to Shipshewana, IN we had tickets to see Bill Anderson, We had a great Dinner and saw a wonderful show. I had a free Birthday meal from the Blue Gate Restaurant which we used the next morning for breakfast. Their food...More
We were in the Shipshewana, IN area to visit an RV manufacturer. We arrived after normal business hours so we searched the area for some homestyle cooking. Our search led us to the Blue Gate Garden Restaurant, smack dab in the middle of Amish Country....More
While visiting the area, my wife and I stopped to the Blue Gate for their smorgasbord dinner. To be honest, we were both quite disappointed. The salad and soup bar was fine, however, we found the entrees and sides to be either bland-tasting, or too...More