Time well spent with family. Service was good and attentive. Classic steakhouse dishes, steaks were cooked perfectly however a few of my family members were not thrilled with having a la carte steaks served with a sauce on the steak and on plate. Perhaps this...is something they missed on menu or it is a signature presentation. Carpaccio was yummy but needed a touch more acid on the arugula. My scallops were cooked perfectly, presentation was beautiful but I did not like the apples with the scallops and the mushroom risotto was on the much drier side. Scallops are sweet enough and do not need a complementing fruit IMO. We had several side dishes, brussel sprouts were overdone to a burnt bitterness, asparagus was cooked perfect and hollandaise was on point. Chocolate Pate for desert was the highlight of my evening! I think a bread pudding would be a perfect addition to the menu. 😉 This is white linen and $$$. For what we paid PP, I wished it had met our expectations from what we read or heard.More

Prime rib was tender, but extra fatty and tasteless. Everyone at the table had over cooked steaks and prime rib. Server was good. Bar choices were mediocre and selections you can get anywhere. Certainly not what you would expect from a high end restaurant. Overall...an ok evening out, but definitely not worth the price.More

Dinner and drinks were great as usual. The most outstanding was the excellent, proactive and friendly service by our waiter, COY TIPTON. Truly, I've not had service like he provided in 10 or more years! Everything to ensuring our eater glasses were never empty to...great recommendations for each course. We'll be back and will ask for Coy Tipton to serve us again!!!More

Great food, great service and very comfortable! As the saying goes “you get what you pay for”.save up and treat yourself, you will be happy you did

My work takes me around the country and affords me the opportunity to sample many great restaurants; steakhouses being among my favorites. We had not been to Peterson's for some time, so I was looking forward to our visit last night. Our server Summer greeted...us with a smile and delivered our wine immediately. I must say that my filet with peppercorn brandy sauce was as good as I have ever had. The Caesar salad, French onion soup and au gratin potatoes were wonderful. GL Rutherford Cabernet perfectly matched my steak. There is also an interesting, less expensive bar menu to enjoy as well. Be sure to try Peterson's if you haven't had the pleasure to do so.More

This place has been on my to do list for a long time. Because of Devour Indy I finally made it. I am glad that I did. It is a bit dark. Great for Romance. Not so great for people with dimming vision - just...bring a flashlight with you. The women's room was clean. They have lotion / tooth picks / mouth wash.... for your convenience. If I was on the above romantic date this would have been amazing Staff are kind and helpful. Parking is easy. They only problem involves getting there from the West. You will have to drive past it then make a "U" turn and return. Be careful during rush hour. The wine was tasty. Our waiter was very knowledgeable when asked for advise. The lobster bisque is wonderful. It is an award winning bowl of soup for a reason. The scallops were tasty and more important not over cooked. The accompanying veggies were also cooked to perfection A friend ordered the pot de creme and really enjoyed it. I ordered the Creme brule' It also was quite tasty. I actually would havve been OK with a smaller serving of the Creme' Brule" Price - This is a special occasion restaurant. This is not your every day grab a meal place. So, find a special occasion and go. Then go back.More

Outstanding restaurant in Fishers! Great for bar dining and service as well as with friends The Caprese and Artisan greens salads were wonderful. The halibut special was also very good!