We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
I wish I would have taken a picture of my piece of pie before I inhaled it!! I picked the lemon and lavender pie. Not for the faint hearted, the crust is sweet cookie pastry with lavender and the lemon is so creamy tart! Perfect...More
We tried to visit Friday night but they were closed. We went Saturday afternoon and found an open table. We each got Caramel Apple Walnut pie warmed up with vanilla ice cream. I also got a hot apple cider. We both loved the pie. My...More
After our initial visit to Myrtle's, no visit to Galena will be complete without a return trip. Besides, there are so many varieties of pies to choose from, it would take many, many visits to try to them. Coffee was great and the french vanilla...More
As others have said this is the best pies I've ever had. Their key lime pie was excellent nice and tart with a flakey crust. Apple to die for. Only problem is being a resident of Galena I avoid downtown on the weekends and roam...More
This is a small shop with about 6-8 tables of varying size, not flashy or fancy in any way. There are approximately 12 types of pies to choose from on a daily basis. My friend and I both stated that it was the best piece...More
How could we have missed Myrtle's Pies? How many times have my wife and I walked past Myrtle's Pies at 228 North Main Street in historic Galena, Illinois, without stopping for a slice? Or going home with two or three whole pies made from scratch?...More
Hubby and I went there on a day trip after reading about it in local paper. Worth the trip! Hubby had coconut cream with awesome merangue. I had pecan. Best pie we ever ate. They only serve pie and cake and coffee. 36 kinds of...More