Brown Bag Seafood on Randolph is my current favorite place to eat in Chicago. I don't get to Chicago often, but I eat there when I do!
I've found their fish to be impeccably fresh and always well prepared.
The atmosphere is lovely, to my...sensibilities. It's a no-nonsense seafood shack, offering a menu that may seem limited, but which actually provides excellent fish in a range of dishes. It's definitely casual, maybe not "date night" material, but it feels authentic, welcoming, efficient, and comfortable to me!
I've always found the place to be clean and inviting, with EXCELLENT staff, great fish, casual and comfortable surroundings, and wonderful views of the park...all in easy walking distance of the Loop. Plus, I find it affordable, even by my Wisconsin standards.
My current favorite is the bowl with grains and veggies. The grains are well flavored and nicely chewy; the veggies are fresh and well prepared...and a great complement to the always delicious fish. I enjoy eating this. It's tasty, but also feels very nourishing and satisfying. I'm not sure how to explain what I mean, but, for me, there's a HUGE difference between grabbing some fast food when I just need some calories fast, or eating food that is delicious but not particularly healthy...and eating a meal that is delicious, nutritious, and totally satisfying on all fronts.
What more could one ask for? It's my go-to when I'm in Chicago.More