Carried out pie from this small store. Be careful when eating the sour cherry pie. I found pits in mine.
1 - 10 of 66 reviews
I have NEVER enjoyed pied. That all changed when I tried the Passionfruit Merinque Pie at Hoosier Mama. So decadent and wonderful. Its a new favorite. I also like the sausage and sage and the lamb hand pies. Flavorful and the crust is perfect. It's...More
Its early Sunday afternoon and 99% of the pies were sold out! Lession learned go early for pie. It felt like I was buying crumbs and pie rejects......😕 My lemon pie was good but not Outstanding to my expectations. If in the area again I...More
Excellent pies, Apple, pecan, etc. great fillings. if you want pies for holiday gatherings this is the place to go. I suggest you order in advance. It's a little hard to spot. It's on Chicago Ave, but the sign is tiny and the front is...More
How can a place that's all about pie be anything other than fantastic? The pies are great, but even if they are all not to your liking, a place that makes only pie is fantastic!
They have the best pie in town, kind of expensive but worth every penny. Their passion fruit meringue pie is delicious, always have to get a piece of it or order the whole one online. Their menu changes everyday, check their website to see what...More
Small shop with great pies. Had the dark chocolate cream pie, excellent. Couldn't have been better. Friendly service. Free refills on coffee.