The monstrously large (24”) margarita pizza was fresh, hot and delicious. The ingredients were quality, buffalo mozzarella, homemade-tasting tomato sauce, and we added fresh peppers. This place only does take out. The staff was friendly and delightful. No delivery unless it’s hubgrub and no sit...down area, but if you are looking to feed a crowd and want a quality pizza at an affordable price, this is a great spot.More
Have friends from Chicago that live in the area that told me that they tried the pizza here and it was absolutely not Chicago pizza. I have been to Chicago numerous times and Chicago pizza is my favorite. I eat New York pizza when in...New York but still prefer Chicago deep dish pizza. Thought I would give this place a try because other people that I know mentioned that it was pretty good but none of them have ever been to Chicago. We got the Chicago pizza and when we got it home my wife were disappointed because this is not Chicago pizza. It was a deep dish pizza with cheese that seemed like it had been microwaved and the meat was microscopic and hard to even find. This will be my last time getting a pizza from here.More
While on a weekend get-a-way my wife and I were in Gainesville, GA and were looking for a delivery pizza. We settled on Manhattan Chicago Pizzeria. We ordered the Liberty Supreme Pizza and Mozzarella Sticks. We were told delivery would be about an hour. The...delivery arrived in about hour and fifteen minutes. The pizza was still sufficiently warm, but the Mozzarella Sticks were cold and soggy. The toppings on the pizza were not overly generous and were recklessly placed on the pizza as if thrown on there by someone in a big hurry to rush the pizza's through. All the toppings were spread over about 3/4 of the pizza and the other 1/4 of the pizza had NO toppings. The pizza was basically just your average delivery pizza. Nothing special to make us try it again. Perhaps, if we had ordered in and eaten there it would have been better. Good pizza but nothing to write home about.More
The food here is amazing! The portions are huge and the staff is friendly. They have Chicago and NY pizza. They also have pastas and salads and calzones. SO GOOD!
The people are super nice here. They make authentic Chicago and Manhattan Pizza. SO good, all of it. There is a long wait for the Chicago pizza but it takes longer to prepare and it is absolutely worth the wait. A definite must try.
Twice I have called Manhattan Chicago Pizzeria in Gainesville GA and both times I was told it would be an hour and a half or more and to call another day. Really? How do you plan to stay in business telling customers to "call another...day"? When I drive by, there are few customers inside.More
The wife and I stopped in to check out the new Pizzeria in town, wanted to see if it was what we remember being a New Yorker transformed into a southerner. I went to order and by mistake i orderd a Chicago Deep Dish pie....I really didn't want that but by the time I realized it I just went with it. We took the pie home and it was good, I just can't figure out why a deep dish pie is more expensive than a regular pie. It is about the same size if you laid it out flat and has pretty much the same ingredients. Anyway we will return and get a regular pie next time. Good pie,More
