We've been coming to the Old Tav for the past 10 years, both as a couple dining solo or with the kids. Our experience encompasses sitting at the bar, outside dining on the balcony and every once in a while, smack dab in the middle...of the dining room. Favorite place to sit is at the bar because it's the easiest place to enjoy the food and the company of the person you are dining with.
For the most part, dinners have been wonderful. Our previous visit, which was August of 2021 had us extremely disappointed in the food and service so we were actually hesitant to stop when we were passing through Tavernier during this vacation stay. However it was late and there are very few restaurants open past 9 pm, we we decided to wing it.
We were pleasantly surprised by how much different our experience was ... it helped to compensate for last years thumbs down evening. They were out of the Oysters Moscow - ran out of caviar - so we kept it simple with a traditional Greek Salad (this means no lettuce) and a Tomato Basil Pizza. Note for the pizza, it's not on the menu so you need to know to ask for it ... and if they are really busy, they stop serving them entirely UNLESS you are a local. There are perks to being local here. :D
Interesting combination of Greek and Italian food themes here and something on the menu for people of all ages.More