Super disappointing. First time in Sarasota and a friend recommended it. The waiter couldnt be bothered, the food was mediocre )plates were returenes) and overall experience not good. Would not recommend.

Love this place! This is a must in Sarasota! We absolutely love going here every time we visit. Staff is amazing and the food is the best!! Fluent free pasta and pizza keep us coming back.

Excellent and friendly service by Blake and his team. Linguine and clams and Eggplant Parm were good sized platters and delicious. Patio seating and warm friendly clientele made this an enjoyable dinner. Great Lower Manhattan cocktail too Complimentary valet parking is available.

Checked into our hotel and looking for a place to have lunch. So happy we walked by this place. Wasn’t expecting much since it’s “American Italian”. We were pleasantly surprised how delicious the food was. Pastas were perfectly al Dentè. The beef braised tortellini with...More

We stopped at Caragiulos for lunch. Service was excellent. Our server Kevin recommended the Pollo Paso pizza which was excellent. We also had the Tortelloni ala Vodka which was also very tasty.

A friend introduced us to this wonderful restaurant. We shared the freshest Margarita pizza I believe we have ever had. There was a powerboat show in town, so the restaurant was quite busy. After a short wait, we had a great dining experience. We will...More

We absolutely love this place. We never go to Sarasota without eating here. Awesome food with gluten free pizza and pasta available.