We stopped in here to get out of an unexpected downpour, and were rewarded with wonderful pizza and great service!
1 - 10 of 1,228 reviews
Our family was strolling along St. George street, watching and listening to this guy standing outside Pizzaalley trying to get people to try the best cheesy, crispy pizza he was advertising. I never turned down a sample, so I gave it a try. Two hours...More
This is by far the best pizza available in the area. We normally do not like pizza in FL as we are used to "Yankee" style crust which is normally medium crust that is crispy yet also soft. (Hard to explain). After searching for years,...More
Wow! There are a ton of places to get pizza in St. Augustine but Pizzalley's might just be the best! My family and I recently visited (7/16/17) and all I can say is "WOW"! What a night and day difference between here and another place...More
After touring the fort in St. Augustine in the summer heat, our family decided to chill out on the shaded porch of Pizzalley's while we waited for our pizzas. There was a nice breeze, so we decided to eat out there, too, instead of waiting...More
The free samples they offer is a great draw to get you in the door. Everyday we had to walk past and my son wanted the free taste and several days would get a slice. The 4 is because they tell you the slices are...More
We came here with a family of 22 people. We were able to quickly order and delicious food was received. They had an expansive menu with some unique, but yummy foods. The breadsticks were amazing also! Excellent service, excellent price, excellent food.
This was one of my top 5 favorite pizza places. We happened upon it randomly and since I'm always up for pizza we gave it a try. So good! The crust was crispy and soft all at the same time! I'm not sure how they...More