Went here tonight, it was never as good as the one in Ybor city but it was still pretty good and a place we brought our visitors. The last 2 times the Paella has been very salty, the Palomilla steak did not have a lot...More

Very popular eatery in the center of this touristy town, but it somehow manages to serve hundreds of people with great tasting food, in a large busy setting. Make sure to order their unique appetizers and main courses.

Dave our server was awesome.,made a great sangria. Table side salad was fabulous. Great job Dave!! Very accommodating in the food selections. Paella was Awesome. Would recommend it to everyone but a reservation is necessary.

We always try to make it to Columbia when we are in St. Augustine. Eight of us went there for Valentines Day dinner. My husband and I alwayss get the seafood cannelloni which is amazing (and very rich!). One person got the pork chop and...More

3rd time to Columbia, first time to this one. Columbia St Augustine is just as good as Columbia Ibor City. I was blown away by the Palomilla. Don't miss this restaurant.

Was intrigued by the reviews and the location. It is a beautiful restaurant with a reasonable wait time for those without a reservation. Service wasn’t up to standard for a top tier restaurant. Timing of delivery of appetizers was poor, one finished before the second...More

Walking around downtown in the evening looking for a place to eat...had always avoided eating at Columbia, cuz we have wonderful Columbias close to home. BUT, lucky for us we decided to pop in for some tapas. Lovely decor...excellent service (Brian) our mussels with sausage...More