A friend has raved about this pizza for the past 5 years and finally had the chance to try it. Picked up a pie to go and it was delicious!! Perfect ratio of toppings, cheese, sauce, and crust. Sad that it's over an hour away...More

Seriously love Carmelo’s! Delicious food, friendly service, pleasant atmosphere- you cannot go wrong! Garlic knots are wonderful! Added bonus- clean restrooms😊

This pizzeria is built into Carmelo's "Marketplace" -- so it's pretty much one-and-the same as the convenience store it abuts. Problem is, nothing "convenient" about the "Convenience Store//Pizzeria, beyond its proximity to the Old City. The Quality and service is substandard, as compared to Romano's...More

Located in central St. Augustine in a gas station. Can be a little "off-putting" on first visit. But the food is very good. Casual, with wide variety of Italian foods, but pizza is the specialty. Crust is firm but not crunchy, and toppings are all...More

Stromboli and Service was AMAZING! The marinara sauce was homemade and could be bottled and sold it was So Good! Wishing I was back there to eat another one!

Friendly welcome made us feel right at home. Nice menu selections. Pizza was good. We love a thin crust pizza. No complaints. A good solid meal value.

Read about Carmello’s at hotel. Well worth the trip. Their pizza was some of the best I ever had. They have a 2 slice special at reasonable price.