Very unique setup being inside a Shell station right in town. We ordered a small pizza (6 generous slices) and it was the perfect size for me and my husband. Our waitress was very friendly and even went into the station to select a seltzer...for me! We enjoyed the food, service and prices!More
Attached to a gas station and is pretty small but don’t let that fool you. This is the best pizza in St. Augustine! in my opinion! Very friendly staff as well. We always make a stop to Carmelo’s when we’re visiting St. Augustine.
Amazing! They have amazing pizza! The cheese pizza is the best I have ever had. The mozzarella sticks are huge and taste so good. The prices are great, and the portions are huge.
Great pizza from a corner gas station - don't let the location fool you. This is some flavorful pizza, NY style, made with fresh ingredients.
Went looking for someplace to eat on a Sunday night close to 10:00 PM in Saint Augustine Florida. Found Carmelo’s. Open the door and the smell was heavenly! The staff was very friendly and extremely helpful. I had the antipasto salad and garlic knots. My...friend had vegetable pizza and a small side salad. The prices were great and the food was excellent. Would highly recommend you give them a try.More
This pizza place is inside a gas station but the food is delicious. Don’t be afraid to order you won’t be disappointed. The Stromboli was very nice size and very tasty along with the peanut butter pie Staff could have done better with hand washing...and hygiene. A lot of touching mask without washing hands. Manager needs to re enforce Servsafe standards. Being an instructor you could see a lack of training and enforcement with food safety principlesMore
In St. Augustine for a little get-a-way; still a bit concerned about dining in so we ordered for delivery. In the mood for pizza and wings. Had the meat supreme, a slice of veggie pizza, buffalo wings, fried calamari, Caesar salad, side Greek salad, and...cheese cake for desert. Though the order was delivered later than expected, we received a text message to inform us of and to apologize for the delay, which was greatly appreciated. The pizza was tasty but not piping hot as we expected; not a big deal; just popped it in the microwave to put a bit of heat to it; the wings were good, though the medium sauce seemed to be a bit sweet as well; was not a fan of the sauce. The salads were great and the cheesecake was decent.More
Hungry and needing to eat before touring San Sebastian Winery across the street, we decided to give Carmelo's a try. We sat out on the patio and enjoyed the warm January weather as we ate pizza, salad and a brew. The pizza slices were a...good size and tasty. Don't pass it by!More
Nice and cheesy vegetarian pizza. The base for soft even after I stored and ate later. Really loved the taste and one slice was enough for my dinner
While on vacation, we stopped here for a quick lunch. We had individual slices, the garlic knots and a side garden salad. Everything was amazing. Would definitely recommend.
