We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

Ratings and reviews

#138 of 235 Italian in Orlando


Italian, Pizza
Lunch, Dinner, Late Night
Delivery, Takeout, Wheelchair Accessible, Reservations

Location and contact

Florida Center
3.7 miles from SeaWorld
Improve this listing
Reviews (78)
Filter reviews
38 results
Traveler rating
Traveler type
Time of year
More languages
Traveler rating
See what travelers are saying:
Sort and selected filters
Sort FilterEnglish
Updating list...
Reviewed February 24, 2022

We stayed by Hotel Monreale and ordered pizza here when we arrived 11pm from NYC. Thank goodness they were still open. We all loved our pizza.

Date of visit: February 2022
Reviewed August 9, 2021

The food was good. The problem that I had is that my delivery driver spoke no English whatsoever. The driver had such a hard time processing my payment and there was no explanation why. we finally got it processed. I tried texting him and he...could not read English either. With the Spanish that I do know it is like he still could not help me.More

Date of visit: July 2021
Reviewed February 22, 2021 via mobile

Ordered carry out pizza order online (through Menufy) which was slick & easy. However when I went to pick up my order, things changed. First, the place is hard to find, in an industrial looking strip mall off the beaten path with NO sign out...front distinguishing it as a business let alone a restaurant. I saw 2 people and went inside to ask directions. The lady helping understood little to no English. Appeared to à conservative Hebrew establishment with "Kosher" meats and "vegan" cheese. I asked the lady 3 times of she knew where Broadway NY pizza was, no reply. However a stack of glossy advertisements were sitting on the desk with "Broadway NY Pizza" menus on them. I finally realized this WAS the place. An older gentleman with better English emerged from the back and confirmed. No pick up order was ready. After discussion, he said they hadn't received my order and there was lively phone discussion with apparently a Menufy rep. To his credit, the older gentleman was nice and apologetic, asked me what I ordered, told me 12 minutes, and slipped off to make it. 25 minutes later (and NO customers or phone calls at all during this time; I'm the only guy) I received a large half cheese/half meat lovers pizza and an order of garlic knots. The was below average bordering on bad. The pizza looked terrible: the meat was dark, shrunk, little and indistinguishable scattered haphazardly over 2/3rds of the strange incompletely melted vegan cheese. Crust was good; topping were bad and looked bad. The garlic knots were burnt and tasteless. Bad location, bad communication, bad food. Nice couple, though. Order elsewhere...!More

Date of visit: February 2021
Reviewed November 27, 2019

On my family holiday to Florida we went to the nearest restaurant to the Surfside hotel. Walking up to it the exterior was unclean and disgusting. As we got inside the pizza place it was covered in bugs and the tables hadn’t even been wiped...down. The women laid out out cutlery by dropping it very rude! The cutlery was also unwashed so we ate with our hands. My chicken Cesar salad was horrific the lettuce was covered in black dots but I ate it anyways as I was famished. When we went to pay the lady started shouting in a foreign language when we hadn’t given her a tip so we left as it was so rude. When we arrived back to our hotel room we went to bed all feeling slightly ill. I struggled to sleep but later awoke and was sick everywhere and the holiday was ruined by one restaurant. Please DO NOT GO it’s revolting!!!More

Date of visit: October 2019
Reviewed September 13, 2019 via mobile

I ordered, by phone, a "specialty" pizza from their menu. They insisted that I pay by credit card over the phone before they would even start making it, ok, fine. After the 15-20 minutes they said, I went to the pizzeria to pick up the...pizza. They had made the wrong one? Or they didn't make mine? They tried to give me a different pizza, which I didn't want, nor could I eat. I asked to cancel the order and refund my money, but they said that my pizza was almost ready, 2-3minutes. 10minutes later the manager offered me a can of soda while I waited. A couple minutes after that my pizza was ready. I opened the top and saw that the ingredients were all haphazardly thrown onto one side, and there was more greese on top than cheese. Needless to say, I won't be ordering from them again. On a positive note, their crust was delicious.More

Date of visit: September 2019
Reviewed April 19, 2019 via mobile

Ordered an uber eats and got a notification that it was cancelled an hour after I ordered. Went to bed hungry. Unacceptable. Bad service

Date of visit: April 2019
Reviewed April 4, 2019

the best pizza and salad we've eaten. This place is hard to find but there are new owners so upgrades are being made.The service was fast and friendly. it is a casual, family friendly, pet friendly, hole in the wall that is so worth it.

Date of visit: March 2019
Reviewed January 1, 2019 via mobile

Since I arrived at Orlando I had been wanting to eat real New York Style pizza, and found it here. The great service is a plus. I would definitely recomend it to family and friends.

Date of visit: January 2019
Reviewed October 8, 2018

People from the Northeast BEWARE!! You ask for a large and they send a 14" bar pie for $11.50. Pizza is just ok. The real problem is with the customer service. When we ordered I asked the lady on the phone how much for a...large pie. She said $11.50 which is about right for a 16" pie in New Jersey. The wings we ordered were $7.50 for 10 pieces. This is what the web page said. They charged us $10. The whole bill should have been around $21.50 but for some reason they charged us $26.50. When we called to complain, the manager heard my wife's accent and said that everywhere in America a large pizza is standard 14". I got on the phone and asked him about the extra charges that were added and he couldn't't explain. This place is a rip-off. With the tip to delivery guy, I paid $31.00 for mediocre pizza and bad chicken wings!! Stay the hell away from New York Broadway Pizza!!!! You're better of with Del Giorno!! If you must, order an Extra Large Pie. The standard NYC 16" size. Oh and don't forget to check the web site price because they'll ZIP you here - very dishonest.More

Date of visit: October 2018
Reviewed November 20, 2017 via mobile

We ordered deliver the Philly steak had no steak and the chicken parm was hard never ever again I guess the figure they will never see is again and just didn't care

Date of visit: November 2017
Reviewed October 25, 2017 via mobile

My family, a group of nine, my dad ordered two Pizzas, and 40 wings. They were delivered to the cabana Bay resort. After everyone came up, and said that the wings smelled like fish, I called to let them know to change their oil. First...the guy said he couldn't hear me, so I repeated it all again, he didn't really care. A little while later, my dad called back, and asked for the manager, and they hung up on him. The pizza wasn't bad, and I know that they mostly have tourists, so why would they care? But Eh. Never again!!More

Date of visit: October 2017
Reviewed October 2, 2017

We tried the Broadway New York Pizza and could not believe how good it was if youve ever tasted Pizza in New York then youll know what i mean if you have never tried it then your in for a treat Absolutely Pizza Heaven Fabulous.

Date of visit: September 2017
Reviewed July 7, 2017 via mobile

My brother in law love the pizza in this place but for me it isn't amazing. I had have better pizza in other places. It is an old place with a casual atmosphere. Service is ok.

Date of visit: July 2017
Reviewed May 13, 2017 via mobile

Took a chance eating here and was not disappointed! Pizza and wings were very good. Would definitely eat here next time we visit!

Date of visit: May 2017
Reviewed March 15, 2017

What a fool I was to order pizza from here twice...not once but twice! The delivery takes well over an hour. When the food arrives it is cold and average. After waiting 90 minutes for the delivery each time I called and was was told...the same thing "the driver left ten minutes ago", I gave them two chances thinking one time was a mistake but was disappointed both times. Learn from my mistake and order from someplace else.,More

Date of visit: March 2017
View more reviews
Best nearby
Best nearby hotelsSee all
Hotel Monreale Express I-Drive Orlando
491 reviews
.11 miles away
Motel 6 Orlando International Drive
343 reviews
.15 miles away
Monumental MovieLand
1,818 reviews
.18 miles away
Home2 Suites by Hilton Orlando Near Universal
209 reviews
.19 miles away
Best nearby restaurantsSee all
Red Lobster
950 reviews
.26 miles away
Black Angus Steakhouse
1,833 reviews
.17 miles away
Islands Dining Room at Loews Royal Pacific Resort
887 reviews
.33 miles away
Shogun Japanese Steakhouse
445 reviews
.37 miles away
Best nearby attractionsSee all
Magical Midway
258 reviews
.58 miles away
Universal's Volcano Bay
4,783 reviews
.52 miles away
Alligator Alley
15 reviews
.52 miles away
Orlando Circus School
12 reviews
.01 miles away
Questions & Answers
Get quick answers from Broadway New York Pizza staff and past visitors.
Note: your question will be posted publicly on the Questions & Answers page.
Posting guidelines
Is This Your Listing?
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.
Claim Your Free Listing
Frequently Asked Questions about Broadway New York Pizza

Yes, Broadway New York Pizza offers takeout services.

Yes, Broadway New York Pizza offers delivery services.

Broadway New York Pizza is rated accordingly in the following categories by Tripadvisor travelers:
  • Food: 4
  • Service: 4
  • Value: 4
  • Atmosphere: 3.5