We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
Went with some friends, atmosphere was comfortable and family friendly! Prices were great! We had the cheese pizza, garlic knots, cheesy breadsticks and fried ravioli! All delicious!! Took points off because the chef in the striped shirts kept tasting the sauce and licking his fingers.......I just told my self at least my food all came out cooked!More
Was staying at a local hotel for a business trip. Wanted some good pizza vs. the bootleg hotel pizza.
Had a large pepperoni delivered from I love NY pizza.
Good pie. Perfect size, not too much crust.
Will do again next trip to Orlando.
Order a calzone& was given a 2 oz holder tomato sauce. It was extremely small. I asked for an extra 2 oz of sauce. Waitress stated it would be $1.00. Spoke with manager, she stated is was too expensive but the owner set the price....Ridiculous.More
The food was ok. Calzone was good sized, the Greek salad was the best, but they don't offer Greek dressing! I chose Italian, it was good.
BEWARE GRUBHUB delivery! What a JOKE! they were over an hour late. The driver called the restaurant, who called...me 3 times. He went to the wrong hotel! Just WOW :( Glad my room had a microwave!
When he finally showed up, he just shrugged, sucked his teeth and made a few raspberrys.. shrugged quite elaborately, never even apologized! I'm sure he was probably a great Art Professor in Abu Dabi, but he sure can't deliver food very well in Orlando, Florida!More
We read the reviews on this pizza establishment and decided to give it a try. Located in a strip mall on Semaron Blvd just outside the airport. We entered and noticed lots of New York paraphernalia on the walls and counter. We ordered an XL...Pepperoni and Sausage pie. When we received our pie, it looked great, but once we tasted it, it was even better! It tasted great. We finally found good pizza in our area. The staff was very friendly. The tables and booths are comfortable but someone should wipe them down. Will be back!More
This place is not so near my home but it's worth the drive. Their pizza is as close as you'll get to New York style pizza. The atmosphere is cozy with New York memorabilia on the walls and they usually play songs from Frank Sinatra/Big...band. Prices are very reasonable. I wouldn't go anywhere else. I "Love" NY Pizza!More
We had a very good experience with this restaurant. We ordered the pizza while we were on our way back to the hotel and asked to have it delivered at 6:00. They tried to deliver it at 5:15. We were not there.
After a little...back and forth on the phone, they agreed to deliver it at 6:00. We expected to get a cold or nasty pizza that had been sitting under a heat lamp for an hour. This was not the case. At 6:05, they delivered a fresh hot pizza with breadsticks! They tasted great! Some of the best pizza we've had.More
Was in the hotel decided I did not want to go out for dinner so ordered pizza for delivery online.
Pizza showed up in a reasonable time 30 to 40 minutes.
Pricing was reasonable and we had no issue with this place.
Typical New York...crust, sauce was very flavorful and toppings decent amount.
Yes we would order again.More