All 13 of our family members agree that this is the BEST pizza. We loved it so much we ordered it twice during our week long stay. It is a very expensive pizza, but was worth it to us!

We have been coming to Captiva for years and finally tried the pizza at Captiva Pizza located same side of Andy Rosse as Key Lime Bistro. We were pleasantly surpried. Nice variety of pizza choices and toppings. We will go again in the future.

Trust me when I say you will LOOOVE the pizza at this little pizza joint !!!!!! We got the Cannonball pizza to eat during the super bowl (sorry for the late review) and even with the massive amounts of pizza the owner was making for...More

We drove from sanibel (about 20 minutes with traffic and speed limits of 35. Beautiful drive. Parking was a bit tricky, but we were patient and ended up being able to park in the lot where Captiva Pizza shop was...best beach pizza we’ve ever had....More

Not wanting to miss a minute of the SEC men’s basketball tournament, we decided to get pizza delivered to our vacation rental. The pizza was very good and arrived exactly when promised. We will remember this place if we want delivery again.

This place needs better visibility as they have great pizza and would probably be popular with families if they had more seating and if people knew they were there. If you feel for a good pizza, give this place a try. A good choice for...More

Great pizza, Hand tossed, great flavors, fast, we ate in the restaurant, its small with only 2 tables but clean with a very friendly staff, it can be hard to find because of its location, needs a flashing sign above their door once you get...More