Tried to order and was told they just received an order for 50 pizzas and they could not accommodate an order. I think if someone needed 50 pizzas it would have been ordered in advance. They should just tell you they are too busy rather...than make up stories.More
We are very grateful for the large orders this time of year and do our best to accommodate everyone we can in a limited amount of time each evening. We hope you try us again!
Called to order pizzas for the family and we’re told that they had a large party and couldn’t take any outside orders. They gave no further information, the parting comment was was we hope you understand. It was Unfortunate because we had never tried this...pizza place before and we do not understand how one party can close down a restaurant.More
We are very grateful for the large orders we received that evening and the parties we were able to serve; we do our best to accommodate everyone within a limited amount of time. We hope you try us again!
First night on Captiva, the pizza was very good! Great flavor. We picked up our's due to delivery time but would highly recommend. Please is either pick-up or delivery only.
Thank you very much for your kind review! We hope to see you again soon!
We tried the veggie and hawaiian and both were good. good quick dinner to take a break from dining in. Quaint little shop on the second floor
Thank you for your business! We hope to see you again soon!
Really liked the pizza. Had a pepperoni and Captiva Island. Only downside is had to order two in order for it to be delivered. Fortunately we will be on island for a few days si leftovers work.😄 Definately recommend.
Thank you for your business and nice review!
For ppl reading this review, please be patient and understand that everyone is short staffed so if you need to call a time or two, be patient but the pizza is SO yummy and we will continue to count on Captiva Pizza. We love it!!...We have realized that calling early vs waiting until calling during dinner hour helps reduce wait time. Do try this pizza, it’s delicious and owned independently by a small business owner, be patient and go for it! It’s great pizzaMore
Thank you for your kind words! We hope to see you again soon!
Our family stayed in a condo on Captiva. Our last night we just wanted some simple food and thought pizza would be the best option. Captiva pizza is one of the only reasonable local options for pizza. Play seems to be run by one guy...who was working like crazy. I had to wait on the phone for several minutes because he was working with other customers in the shop. Pizza was ready on time and the overall taste and quality of the food was quite good. Not the best I’ve ever had but it hit the spot that evening.More
Thank you for your business and patience! We look forward to seeing you again soon! We work very hard but it makes it really great when people are happy and enjoy their vacation and pizza! :-)
Ordered 3 pizzas for our family….were ready on time….great crust and toppings….gentleman making pizza and manning the counter was polite and helpful….would definitely order again
Thank you for your kind words! We look forward to seeing you again!
man behind the counter had no interest in serving us. when we reached the counter he said if we knew exactly what we wanted he could take our order and walked away. when we called him back and told him what we would like he...very abruptly took our order, abruptly answered one question about what gf crust was, which by his attitude we were obviously supposed to know, and said 45 min and walked away. we cancelled our order as he obviously did not need our money.More
We hope you try us again!
Amazing pizza Skinny pirate all the way!! We will Make this a regular stop every trip now Sooooooooo good If you don’t try the pizza you are missing out
Thank you very much for the nice review we hope to see you again soon!
Good pizza! We ordered takeout pizza and it was really good. Oh her cheese and specialty bread was cooked perfectly and we were all pleased. Definitely an easy evening meal while on Captiva.
Had to put our pizza in oven when we got home to cook and crisp it up! Come on! Cook it for 5 more minutes. Plus recvd black olives when asked for green. Get a frozen one from gas station or market. You will be...better off.More
The crust that you ordered was the Gluten Free option, this is parbaked crust and has much different consistency than our fresh hand tossed pizza crust. — We have this as an option for people who cannot have our regular dough due to allergies. Thank...More
Horrible service! Unable to get a cell connection due to the storm. Tried to order a pizza in person and was rudely told to go outside and order by phone. Tried explaining that I did not have a cell connection and then was told to...get eat somewhere else!More
I understand your frustration, thank you for bringing this to our attention. Due to short staffing we asked that orders to be called so we could serve customers as quick take out as possible. It can be loud in the kitchen and that must of...More
Totally fine but nothing to run home about. But hey, we were on vacation and didn’t feel like cooking or going out, so this did the trick.
Glad you enjoyed your pizza! Hope you had a great vacation!
Ownership clearly has no regard for current recommendations regarding masks. Employees were maskless...while making our food....during a pandemic. No need to say anything else. Will not be back. Will spend our money at establishments that respect current medical recommendations.
We regard the United States Constitution as the law and respect freedom and always will. —