Took over an hour for orders for 4. Wasn't very busy so not sure why. Server checked on us once after the food was delivered.
Is this a Bahamian restaurant?
Is this restaurant appropriate for Kids?
Is this restaurant good for large groups?
Does this restaurant serve Bar / Pub food?
Does this restaurant serve lunch?
Does this restaurant serve dinner?
Does this restaurant serve breakfast?
Does this restaurant offer takeout or food to go?
Does this restaurant offer outdoor seating?
Does this restaurant offer validated parking?
Thanks for helping!Share another experience before you go.
What a surprise this place was and full of atmosphere . Great watching families having fun feeding the fish and being shown how to gut and clean fish they caught. A family next to us had their catch cooked to their specification which is awesome . Our meal was lovely, portions large and sadly couldn't finish it. I had Mahimahi... More
I'm glad you enjoyed your meal with us. Come back and see us next time you're in town! More
First time having hogfish and it was delicious. The atmosphere was a cool outdoor area overlooking the water and people feeding the Tarpon. We would go again.
I'm glad you enjoyed your meal with us! More
The outside bar molds into outdoor restaurant.. lots of smoking at bar.. will affect your meal.. go for breakfast..
Smoking is only permitted at our bar area, we have plenty of seating available that is smoke free. Thank you for your time. More
The only thing this restaurant had going for it was the water view. Food was cold, from the fries to the clam chowder , and wait staff was unprofessional. Our waitress picked up one of the dressing cups to see if it was tartar sauce or ranch and then proceeded to smell it. After determining that it was tartar sauce... More
I do apologize for your experience not being up to our standards in service and quality. We hope that you please reconsider and come back to let us redeem ourselves and show you how amazing not only our view is, but also our food and friendly staff. Also because the tartar sauce incident is absolutely unacceptable it would be a... More
Great local Key West hang out. Excellent food as well. Staff was friendly and helpful. Shopping is good at the craft market and Tarpon are definitely worth seeing.
I am glad you enjoyed your visit! Come back and see us next time you're in Islamorada! More
Traveled with my adult kids to Key West and stopped at the Hungry Tarpon for lunch. Would definitely return. Their bloody Mary's are almost a meal by itself!
I am glad you enjoyed our bloody! Come back and see us next time you're in town! More
Ate at the Hungry Tarpon on July 4th. The catch of the day I ordered wasn't tasty. It was a whole fried fish. And apparently when they say "whole" they mean it. Beside the guts and the scales of the fish, NOTHING else was removed lol! But that's fine with me. It could be seasoned better. But the seafood pasta... More
Our whole fried fish is a fried fish served whole, as applied by its name. I apologize if it wasn't appealing to you, but most of our guests find it quite tasty! I'm glad you enjoyed your pasta! More
Always stop in either coming or going through the keys. A really neat place. Very very busy with the holiday weekend. Daughter has the cheese quesadilla and thought it was very good. My wife and I each had the grilled mahi and Cole slaw. Very well done. Always great tasting slaw and the mahi was perfect. Empty plates all around.... More
Thank you for taking the time to write us, we really appreciate the feedback from our customers. We are a high volume establishment but we take pride in the service we provide to our customers. More
Decided to get a bite to eat after feeding the tarpon at Robbie's. The Bloody Mary had a great presentation but lacked flavor. I wasn't a big fan of the cucumber vodka and it didn't have any kick to it(we had to add a lot of pepper and Tabasco to it). We ordered the smoked fish dip and Thai fish... More
I apologize you were not happy with your experience with us. All of our seafood is served fresh in order to provide the best taste experience for our customers. Our waitresses/waiters are trained to provide the best service possible and anything below perfection is unacceptable. Come back and see us again, I promise you won't be disappointed. More
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.Claim Your Listing