Had lunch on the patio and only 2 other tables were seated. The waiter was very friendly. Ordered the blue crab Benedict. First of all it was NOT blue crab. The English muffin was sticky, cold and not toasted, the crab was likely from Asia...and very inferior to blue crab, the eggs were cold, the potatoes were cold, the bacon might have been cooked the day before. Extremely disappointing and very expensive. Will not be back.More

What a fantastic menu,drink options and the service first class. Great specials and ambiance. Our last day here and the best experience for last.

We arrived at the host desk to give our name Four people were already waiting No host for 10 minutes I went inside restaurant to ask where the host was A waiter said she’s coming-not for 5 more minutes Finally she appeared and asked how...many in each party Then she disappeared again When she finally returned she seated one party Another long wait She asks if everyone in the parties were present-we were-she finally seated us There were many empty tables We waited 10 more minutes for a waiter I ordered coffee and was never offered a refill nor did the waiter check on usMore

NOT gluten-free friendly for breakfast. No gluten free bread or grits for breakfast & no substitutions, so my celiac husband had an omelet on a large plate without even a garnish. He couldnt eat the included toast or muffin. My french toast was dry as...if microwaved. They seemed to be pushing boozy drinks at 9am. No plain orange juice on the menu! Sarabeths was a favorite of ours 12 years ago, but it sure has changed and we wont be going back.More

Best brunch ever. Shrimp Mac and cheese, shrimp and crab cheese grits snd lobster BLT. Great device also. We are leaving feeling super fat, could not stop eating.

Friendliest people, amazing food, and the key lime French toast-probably the best food item I’ve ever had. This is an incredible place and I’m glad we found it. Please put one up here on Marco Island!!

My husband waited out front for quite a bit, just to talk to a hostess or server. I think they were short staffed, but doing their best. Got seated and our server came over to tell us the specials, etc. He spoke very fast and...I could hardly understand him, but he was in a rush, so I understand. Our breakfast was very good and considering there were only two people working the entire floor, they did a great job. Eggs benedict with spinach was great. Coffee was great. Some coconut mimosa thing, great.More

Been wanting to come to Sarabeth's for a while now and finally did it for breakfast. Wow...really good. Relaxing atmosphere and wait staff were fabulous. Brad, one of the wait staff, seems to be the celebrity there as when I posted we were there many...responded to me asking to say hi for them. We did. Great guy. I had the traditional breakfast....really good and my wife had the French Taste with almonds and bananas...in the words of George Takei from Star Trek...."OH MY!!" Really good. Funny, I ordered a coffee and when they brought it I as like..."I didn't order soup!" That's how big the cup was....Loved it!! We sat at a cozy little spot with a big window looking out to the street. Was relaxing to watch the world go by. Recommend making this a place to go when in Key West...I know we'll be back.More

Brunch is absolutely amazing. The eggs Benedict was truly prefect. The eggs were cooked to my order and the omelette was delicious. The mimosas were excellent and the blueberry muffin was divine! The service is top notched!

Charming location. Flawless service. Exquisite food. Must haves: Spinach and Feta cheese omelet. The toast with butter and jam. Some of the best coffee I’ve ever had (you must love strong coffee). Oh and the coconut key lime mimosa…….RI-DI-CU-LOUS!

Amazing lunch and staff. Had the special lobster sandwich and homemade cream of tomato soup. Yummy Also the Key Lime Cream pie, and we shared this meal which was plenty for two. Just superb!

We are Key West locals and this is our favorite brunch spot! It never disappoints. Brad will make your day! He is the best!! Food is amazing, literally anything. You have to try the blueberry muffin!