I came here for a late-ish dinner without a reservation and was made very welcome. As it was a cool (cold for Key West) evening they weren't seating outdoors which was fine with me. Sometimes it's really awkward eating solo in restaurants but not here....More

Best breakfast on the island. Ate here on our last day and it was amazing. French toast was fat and fluffy just like it's name. Very moderately priced. Worth the trip off the beaten path.

We were looking for someplace to go for an early dinner and noticed that Sarabeth's was nearby. We love the NY locations and were happy to learn that there was a Key West location. I had a hard time choosing something to have because it...More

Went to this restaurant our first night in key west it is known for its breakfast but the dinner was great you are greeted by the friendliest guy ever the restaurant looks like it was an old church it’s very pretty the shrimp and grits...More

With a vegetarian in the family, I look for places that have a decent selection for meat and veggie eaters. We decided upon Sarabeth's today and it was a great meal. My boys ate the mac-n-cheese with a green chili flair while the wife had...More

We have passed by Sarabeth's many times in KW but never stopped before. Big mistake. We stopped this year and had a wonderful surprise. The atmosphere is great, the service excellent and the food beyond belief. My wife is a notoriously picky eater and always...More

Had an early morning pre wedding brunch with the girls here. It was incredible. The almond crusted cinnamon French toast was to die for!! My one friend gaf their famous tomato soup with smoked mozzarella sandwich and it was amazing. We all had fresh tasting...More

We visited this place on a rainy Sunday morning. We had around a 20 minute wait and spent the time trying to stay dry on the small front stoop. However, once we were seated we enjoyed some good, strong coffee and some incredible omelets had...More

It's not like eating at denny's or something like that. If you are looking for quick and just ok, this isn't the place. Sarabeths has a different agenda. The service is very personalized. We were waited on by milosh and Maggie, and I felt like...More

Staff was fantastic. Food was a-m-a-z-i-n-g. Friendly environment overall, made new friends. Will be going back!