We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
Tripadvisor gives a Travelers’ Choice award to accommodations, attractions and restaurants that consistently earn great reviews from travelers and are ranked within the top 10% of properties on Tripadvisor.
While the food here was good, it’s nothing to write home about and I wouldn’t think of this place first for another meal. This place is for you if you like to people watch, it’s in the heart of Duval toward the end of Mallory...Square, the place was clean and the waitstaff friendly otherwise,More
The atmosphere here is nice. Locals tend to hang out here and it’s location is great for people watching. The conch fritters were not good but the tuna was excellent. The frozen drinks from the Flying Monkey bar made this a great meal. Bathrooms were...dirty and smelly.More
Stopped here last year so we had to come back. Nice outdoor atmosphere with fans. It’s on Duval Street so there’s always a lot of fun people watching. We had drinks and appetizers for an afternoon snack. The Mahi Bites were wonderful but the peel...and eat shrimp were so amazing that we ordered another pound. Joanne was our server and she was great. Would definitely go back.More
Date of visit: October 2020
bestrestaurantskw, Agency / Consultant at Fogarty's, responded to this reviewResponded 3 weeks ago
Thank you for coming! We agree, Joanne is great! Come visit us again soon!
I've eaten here twice within the last week. The $12.00 fish sandwich and fries is a very good deal. However I was disappointed with the drink menu. Drinks were listed as
being $8.00 for 16 oz. Cups. However we were charged $10.00 instead. Our waiter...said it was because we ordered them on the rocks. But he failed to mention this when he took our orders. Unfortunately we deducted the $4.00 difference from his tip. Hopefully this is a learning lesson for him.More
Outdoor seating looked nice and we saw the selection of frozen drinks so decided to stop. We were seated by a nice young man and that was the end of our dining experience. We sat there about 25 minutes waiting to be served and were...completely ignored! After that time after watching people all around us being waited on we got up and moved on. This was our only bad experience in Key West. So many better options than to be treated badly!More
Date of visit: October 2020
bestrestaurantskw, Marketing at Fogarty's, responded to this reviewResponded October 11, 2020
Hi there— I’m so sorry this happened. We made a mistake and our management is working on fixing this problem. Thank you for your feedback, it helps us provide better service in the future.
Walking down Duval, packed restaurants all around -- Fogartys was able to seat us right at the front so we can do all the people watching we wanted! Our server was excellent - he had been there 8 years. Highly recommended.,