We have visited Key West for the past 15 years, and visited this restaurant many times every trip. We decided to take first time visiting friends, so they could experience our favorite restaurant. Tom, as usual, gave excellent service. Everyone left happy and full!

Of the restaurants we went to during our week in Key West this was the best restaurant. We had a reservation so we didn't have to wait. Their garlic knots are okay. I love garlic but their knots were a little too much for me....More

we had dinner with friends last night food was great an Kamil was our waiter he was great service with a smile and a positive attitude which is always welcome as a customer Kamil is an asset to New York Pasta Garden and we hope...More

The Food is delicious, the servings are just eating at your Grandmothers home, A LOT of food! The Staff is extremely friendly, making you feel like Family. Jeanette provides Great service and a warm Smile at Our Godfather Table. if you sit inside it has...More

This place is horrible! The worst place to go to pay for a $30 plate dinner. The wait for us to get a waitress took forever. I ordered a plate with scallops, lobster chunk, and shrimp with pasta but got scallops and fish. I'm not...More

The service was excellent and so was the food, with huge portions. The waiter was very helpful with explaining the cources on the meny and after the dinner he showed up with one of their birds and we were allowed to take photos with the...More

Nice to find every once in a while good Italian food in US. This is one of this places. On top of that very good wine and service. Shrimp carbonara was very good and salad also perfect. But the best dish was tuna starter -...More

Enjoyed outside seating. Staff were friendly and helpful. Server poured me the largest glass of wine I’ve ever had at a restaurant and she brought us complimentary appetizer of fried artichokes...amazing! Pasta entrees were great!

We’ve been coming to Key West for several years. This is our family’s favorite place to dine. The service is outstanding and, of course, so is the food. We each had pasta on this trip. I had the shrimp carbonara, my wife and daughter had...More

Such a shame, we went here with high expectations and were dissapointed.... not by the food but by the service. Our server janette was a friendly lady so let me explain. We ordered our starters calamari and the coconut shrimp, janette gave us garlic dough...More