We were introduced to NY Pasta by friends who are regular customers. Fantastic service and meal-you will not leave hungry! We highly recommend NY Pasta to all of our friends who visit Key West!

Lobster Ravioli was fantastic! We found this place on Trip Advisor before our trip started. We made it a plan to eat here. The night we ate here it was raining, so no outdoor seating, but the service and meals were awesome. If this place...was in my hometown, I’d be a regular.More

We went here on recommendation of couple from Denver and we’re not disappointed! Theor appetizer of artichoke hearts is absolutely delicious! Everyone loved their dishes which included chicken Marsala, clams, Shrimp all over pasta. The side salads were beautiful and very tasty. The garlic knots...we shared were very good. Huge glasses of wine🥂 Service provided by our waiter Darius was excellent. Highly recommend going here!More

Friendly staff, very reasonable prices on wine, and overall nice atmosphere. This was our first night in key west. We didn’t make reservations and did an early walk in. They were very accommodating.

We were excited to try this place, but were pretty disappointed. I will stress that the while the food wasn’t awful, it wasn’t great either. My husband ordered the flank steak and when the waiter tried to talk him into ordering it medium well I...was shocked. He finally ordered medium and said it had good flavor, but the garlic mashed potatoes were bad. I tasted them & they tasted like the garlic was rancid. My frutti di mere had good flavor but the sauce had the consistency of water and the mussels and clams had no flavor and didn’t want to come out of their shells. My husband ordered the cannoli and while it looked great, it had no flavor. If you want dessert order the Key Lime pie, it was good. The atmosphere outside was nice and the service was okay. I just didn’t feel that anything we ate justified the prices we paid. We have had these same dishes all over the states and Italy and had them much better.More

They do not know what is pasta “al dente”, all our pastas were overcooked. My kids did not even finished their desserts, and that is a sign. It was not tasty, at all. Very disappointing. And yes, they get you a huge glass of wine,...but this do not save a situation.More

We have never found this place before but we will be back for sure! The food is great and their ambiance is even better!