Tommy provided the greatest service! And the food was wonderful! Salmon was excellent. Veal Marsala was to die for. Stuffed shells florentine is excellent. Portions are large so enough for another meal. Highly recommended to locals and tourists.

Had dinner here during our visit to the Keys and it was great! Miles our waiter was friendly and served us many bread rolls in butter/oil and parmesan cheese. Soooo good. We had chicken gorgonzola, veal piccata and chicken marsala and each plate was huge and yummy! The chef also was serving complimentary fried artichokes appetizers that were a pleasant... More 

The outdoor seating was a treat because it came with a surprise, live parrots who responded to you if you talked to them! The food was amazing as was the service. Our waiter Myles was a pro (and I used to work as a waiter so I can appreciate someone who is on top of their game.) He was courteous... More 

We took a private fishing trip and then took our fresh to New York Pasta Garden for preparation. They made our fish 2 different ways and made sides of pasta veggies and potato to compliment our fish. Food was outstanding and the srtvice from Tommy was impeccable. He was so attentive and kind to us. We will go there every... More 

A few years back, we were looking to find a quiet spot off of Duval Street and stumbled across a very quaint and interesting restaurant. The New York Pasta Garden has absolutely beautiful outdoor seating in the midst of lighted trees, cool breezes, Sinatra music and the like. All of their meals are of the highest quality and an absolute... More 

That's true...we went three times during our week and the food and service were fabulous. The waiter was so friendly, and kept telling us about the great food made by the chef, then bringing us small samples. The food was delicious, and the service was spit on. Every night we visited, there were strong crowds. The waiter we really liked... More 

We had a group of 11 and were able to make a reservation day of. The location was very convenient and we were able to walk to New York Pasta Garden from our AirBnB on Duval street. We had great, friendly service. Our waiter was Tom and he couldn't have been better at accommodating our large group. The meal and... More 

My wife and I were in the mood for some Italian food so we chose this restaurant. It wasn't the closest of the two Italian restaurants nearest our resort but it was the more highly rated.They have alfresco dining but we chose to eat indoors. The décor inside is a little devoid of character but clean and tidy nonetheless. We... More