We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
Tripadvisor gives a Travelers’ Choice award to accommodations, attractions and restaurants that consistently earn great reviews from travelers and are ranked within the top 10% of properties on Tripadvisor.
All reviews oysters coconut grouper peel and eat shrimp onion rings salad stone crab key lime pie happy hour half price price appetizers great seafood people watching outdoor seating marina tarpon boats dock
We came here two nights in a row we enjoyed the food service so so but the oysters were fresh and they have an amazing happy hour menu!
It’s definitely very touristy some of the dishes are not that great and others are ok. The...seafood pasta was so so they need to learn how to make Marinara sauce there’s taste like cheap jar sauce !
But the peel your own shrimp are so good!! Super fresh and enjoyed the clams !
And the first night we went we had an amazing server she’s Eastern European ! Service was spot on ! The next night we had an American girl terrible service and had a bad attitude!More
Dinner was much better than expected. We weren’t sure based on the mixed reviews but everyone enjoyed their meal. The spicy pasta was great and I really liked the clam chowder. The seafood boil was great as well. Service was quick and friendly. Would certainly...come back here!More
The restaurant is well-located on a busy waterfront board-walk and you can eat inside or outside. The food is mediocre and old-fashioned. My seared tuna arrived virtually cold and with what seemed to be a commercially bought seaweed salad. The linguine in the seafood pasta...was over-cooked with a glutinous Alfredo sauce. They only offer 4 varieties of oyster and one of them was unavailable. The hostess who welcomed us was quite unfriendly. Our party of three had booked an outside table in advance (pandemic) and she took us to a table on the windy side of the restaurant which was enclosed behind canvas and plastic sheeting, When we asked to be changed to the less windy side which was fully open, she said there were other reservations there and we couldn't change. We checked during the meal and at least 3 tables where we had asked to be seated were empty the whole time. I would not return or recommend.More
Out of all the restaurants we visited while in Key West, this was our favorite. The food was delicious, no complaints. And the drinks are great as well. I am not a key lime fan but I tried their key lime drink and it was...on point. It was well worth it.More
Went for happy hour. We requested the mussels be cooked with garlic and wine, rather than diablo. They were great. Waitress friendly. Friendly local crowd coming in off the boats, fun to talk to. Would not recommend the fish bites, but the mussels and key...lime colada were excellent.More
I normally don’t write reviews but this time I couldn’t help myself. The food at the restaurant was amazing and the service was great. Stefan was very professional and attentive to our needs. We had a great time thanks to him and the service he...provided.More
There are so many wonderful and well rated places to eat! We also ate at Bagatelles for brunch, and a tapas place (Santiago) for dinner, but no other place for oysters. Sorry that I cannot be of more help regarding oyster... More
There are so many wonderful and well rated places to eat! We also ate at Bagatelles for brunch, and a tapas place (Santiago) for dinner, but no other place for oysters. Sorry that I cannot be of more help regarding oyster restaurants. Have fun!