This place is small and quaint. I had a slice of the key lime pie and was not disappointed! It had the perfect amount of sweet and tart, creamy, cool, and so refreshing on a hot summer’s day!

We are in search of the best key lime pie in the area. This was a string contender for #2. It is very well made. The tart filling is super strong. My husband tried the coconut key lime and it was the best of our...order.More

My only desert weakness is Key Lime pie so I had to try some in Key West. We stopped here and was glad I did. It was perfect! I’m just sad I couldn’t take some home..

Delicious, fresh key lime pie here! We prefer the extra-tart because it's a little more "limey". Friendly staff, clean restaurant, yummy snacks!

We visited the Key West pie company in May of 2022. We walked in the store and found they removed all of Pete's Candy and the shop only had one display and was very sparsely decorated. We tried the pie and the filling tasted more...like a pudding than a key lime filling, we were disappointed in the flavor and the shop itself. I love Key Lime Pie and tried 6 different ones in the 4 days I was in the Keys, I love "The Profit" but this was in the bottom 2.More

the best key lime pie on the whole island! first time trying and even my dad liked it who isn’t a crazy fan of key lime pie. we are still craving it!

Title says it all. Key lime pie was just above grocery store key lime pie. Also got grilled cheese which was great and good coconut shrimp.

They have the best key lime so delicious. Cute items in the store. Good place to pick up key lime gifts to take home. Tried to buy somethings at the Publix and they had nothing Key Lime.

Obviously wanted a slice of Key Lime Pie while in Key West and found this place. They did slices and full individual pies and you could see them making it too. Very clean place as well. This must be the place to go to as...the cycling tour guides took their customers in as wellMore

they do have the key lime ice cream, not found at too many other places! we tried the key lime pie and the key lime cake...very nice

OMG - what a way to end a most enjoyable bike tour with a most exquisite slice of key lime pie! Freshly made and absolutely delicious. Thanks to the magic hands that made it.

I was in the Florida Keys and had to get my key lime pie fix . I have been eating pies from this company for over 20 years. After the company got help from the Profit Marcus Lemonis, the taste improved and was great. This...trip I bought a whole pie and was disappointed . The 15 or 20 minute drive home in a cooler with a bag of ice still softened the pie so the consistency wasn’t optimal which is my fault . However the taste was blah , not much lime . Tasted like it was mostly whipped cream . The crust was awful. It tasted like a store bought ready made graham cracker crust. A cheap one. We didn’t finish the pie which is unlike us. I went by the actual Greene St. Store to try it there to see if those were any different. I was told by the staff that it was the same recipe as what they ship to the stores where I got it so I just left . I wasn’t interested in eating it again. I use to haul several pies in a cooler 500 miles home years ago. I can make a better one at home now. I’m questioning whether they’ve gone back to old habits with lots of ingredients. At least for the ones shipped to the convenience stores. It may be just me but I won’t be buying these pies anymore. I feel sad about that family tradition being lost.More