Very quaint place. Service and food were both great. Price point was reasonable given quality. Nice hat they also offered a small selection of meals for kids.
1 - 10 of 1,452 reviews
HOLY heck ya'll. This place is for real. First of all, locals eat here, which is telling. This restaurant is situated in the middle of a neighborhood, so you have to know ab it to find it. Seriously, I was worried for a minute walking...More
Had the opportunity to go to the restaurant on a recent trip to Key West with friends. There were 6 of us, all with varied tastes and needs. The variety of the menu was perfect for us and it was all delicious!!!! Can't wait to...More
Our pleasure! Scot, Co-Owner, The Flaming Buoy Filet Co.
Went for a girls trip, have been to key west dozens of times but always used to eat wherever we ended up at dinner time. This time, my OCD friend made reservations at a place she heard of. At first, I fought her on the...More
Thanks so much! We look forward to feeding you again. Scot. Co-Owner, The Flaming Buoy Filet Co.
As frequent visitors to Key West we finally tried The Flaming Buoy for dinner. We were pleasantly greeted and taken to our table. The waiter was very nice and explained the menu and answered all our questions. The food was very very delicious. Service was...More
Thank you! Scot, Co-Owner, The Flaming Buoy Filet Co.
This was our favorite place to eat while we were in Key West. We went on recommendation from a friend and it was the perfect place for us. Made reservations by calling before we left on our trip. It is small and has limited tables...More
Thank you for your review. So pleased to read you enjoyed yourselves! (It's funny that you should mention dress. At 46 (August of last year), I decided that this year I should probably start dressing my age. You know, button down shirts. Pants. Shoes that...More
We found this place because we were looking for something off of the main strip. Something different! And pleased we were. Amazing food, Lobster Mac and cheese was amazing. Shrimp grilled perfectly! Great friendly service. Couldn't have had a better experience. And if your a...More
Thank you for the nice review. May the fork be with you. Always. Scot, Co-Owner, The Flaming Buoy Filet Co.
We went to The Flaming Buoy on the recommendation of a friend, and were very thankful we did! Great food and very friendly staff. The atmosphere was eclectic! (Star Wars themed rest room...) Everyone enjoyed the food, even my son who doesn't eat seafood.More
Thank you! About that bathroom: All of those things (and there are tons more in my office in the back of the restaurant) are things I was told by my partner I could not use as decoration in my home. I'd smuggle some Star Wars...More
Decided to try a new restaurant for our anniversary and chose The Flaming Buoy because of its reviews and closeness to our B&B. Thankfully we were not disappointed. We had the appetizer trio with a caprese salad, lobster mac & cheese, and Key West Pink...More
Thank you for the review. Above all else you wrote (I'm glad you enjoyed your food), your review made me very proud to have the staff I have. I'm still not going to give them a raise, but I am proud of them. I hope...More