Nothing I love more than supporting local but not worth a $22 pizza or a $14 Sandwich. Hate to say it but would rather order from papa John’s. -San Carlos location

Opened a second location! We've always enjoyed their pizza and sandwiches on McGregor Blvd! Now they have opened a new location in San Carlos Park. Crispy crust. Hearty sauce. Fresh ingredients, herbs and spices that you can smell. An experience for all of the senses....The picture is their red, white, and green. My favorite! Ricotta, mozzarella, thin slices of sweet tomato, and fresh basil leaves. I love the fact that the basil is added AFTER the baking so that you can taste all of the sweetness! Spouse likes the more meatier pizza toppings. Try it, you'll like it!!More

This is one of the most overhyped places I've ever been to. The food is just straight terrible, to be honest I've had better pizza out of a box from the grocery store. I've tried to palate this awful food several time from the sandwiches...to the pizza your just better of going to a Publix. I don't have enough thumbs to down this place.More

Visited here today for the first time for lunch with the family. Was greeted immediately upon entering by a friendly and professional staff person. She explained the options and was just so friendly. Made you feel welcomed and right at home. Food was made fresh...to order and was delicious. The garlic knots were amazing and filling. Pizza was great and the Chicago Italian beef was so so good. The peppers were a bit spicy for me (but I’m a wimp when it comes to that) but they were delicious. Would definitely recommend and will be returning once we relocate to the area!More

Was searching for pizza tonight and kept scrolling because nothing was catching my eye . And then I saw McGregor Pizza and looked at the address and saw a picture of the front of the store . It hit me like a lightning bolt ....I was so excited . I used to go to this place years and years ago at least 15 years ago . When it was Giovanni. We used to go there as a family with my boys who are now in their late 20’s and early 30’s at least once a week sometimes more to than once lol. It brought back so many memories . I logged on to see the menu and i was so excited to still see some of the treasured items that we used to order . I called to place an order because I was so excited . I ordered 2 pizzas pics attached . I literally had to call my son to tell him where I was going to get pizza because it brought back so many memories. But let me tell you the food is AMAZING !!!!! The service is great also . And please read the story about the owner she is a local so very excited about that also . I will be ordering every time I am in the mood for Italian I promise . My son is coming down next weekend and we will be going there to stroll down memory lane and have some great food . Thank you guys so much for taking me back 20 years and having such amazing foods.More

Went to McGregor for a quick bite and had one of the better pizza's we've had in FLA! The pizza is definitely NY style and we ordered a Cesar Salad which was enough for the two of us. It has a few tables to eat...at, but the takeout was booming and must be the "go too pizza joint" for the locals, because Katie the owner knew everyone that came inl Definitely a come back place to try the sandwiches and strombolis!More

Two NYC area natives searching for pizza in SW Florida........we are ecstatic to have found this place! Really good pizza, perfect crust, kind welcome, friendly service. Worth the drive from Sanibel!

Had delivery last week, the Italian “warm” sub and antipasto were WONDERFUL. We normally get pizza, which is good, but now I’m craving the sub daily. Delivery was fast and food was VERY fresh. I would recommend helping keep this small local business, in business....The food is worth keeping them around.More

Tried the Mediterranean pizza. Overall it was very good. Loved the crust. The only thing they could have done better is add more feta cheese which was one of the ingredients. More of a take out place than sit down.

Yum, just yum. I love the thin crust and the toppings were fantastic. What a great little find! Thanks for the great fast service

Consistently yummy! Each time have gotten 16" extra cheese and extra sauce and it's awesome! Can tell they use quality ingredients! Such tasty sauce and crust and ooey gooey cheese! Haven't tried the desserts yet, plan on next time, they look amazing too! Staff is...always friendly!More

Is great you should try this nowi can't describe how great is everything in this place , TRY NOW PLS