The garlic rolls are awesome Pizza is good Spaghetti and meatballs are great!!! You will not be disappointed
1 - 10 of 199 reviews
I love their eggplant rotolini (spelling?), which is eggplant rolled around cheese. I usually put it over pasta and it comes with a salad. I usually order another side salad and garlic knots and take it home to serve 2. Great pizza as well.
Our first visit from Fort Myers to Deland and our friends suggested going to dinner at Tony's New York Pizza. This popular place was packed and we were lucky to get a table. The ladies split an order of spaghetti and meatballs and thank goodness...More
We love this restaurant and eat here on a regular basis. Tony is very friendly and always makes sure our dining experience is exceptional. The food is outstanding. They have great lunch value meals but my favorite is the Tonys special New York Special with...More
the lunch special was special...garlic knots were served with the beverages...pizza crust was thin and crispy... yet you could still fold in half to eat...try the meatballs...Caprese salad was very good...
Been looking for good pizza restaurant since moving here from CT , we found it!! Crust is thin but was very good. Our new favorite pizza place
My first time eating here: excellent and they have draft and bottled beers to enjoy. Very well run and very clean (they were even cleaning the menu's during my visit!).
Very crowded because the food is so good. Great pizza even better eggplant parm and lasagna including the garlic knots. very nice portions for your hunger
Situated on the corner of New York Avenue and Florida Avenue, it's hard to find a time between 11 a.m. and closing when Tony's isn't bustling with activity. Don't be surprised if you vie for a seat with an entire soccer league, as we did...More
Tony's is overall great. Place is small, and when busy is very loud, lots of people and lots of people coming in and out to pick up orders. The food is great, I have mostly ordered the Greek Salad, pizzas and chicken Parmesan, all were...More