My brother told us to try it. It is definitely off the beaten path but so worth the trip. I had to try the smoked fish dip. It was great and I had fried grouper. Joe had the BLT special and he said it was...the best he had ever had. We also ordered a pizza and took it back to our room for later. It was great. They had great food and service. They were unique because they had dollar bills hanging up all over. You will see in the pictures. We were told many years ago a guy left the bartender a dollar with his name and number on it. They grew from there. Definitely recommend!More

Very unique and different type of place but the food was amazing and priced really good!! The dollars all over the walls and ceilings make waiting for the food fun bc you can look at what all people put on theirs. Couldn’t help but do...a couple of our own. Will be back!!More

We stopped for a bite during our trip down to key west. Our server, David, seemed to be distracted or.maybe slow. Idk. The entire process took two hours, not a quick stop. The food was good, once we finally got it. We sat for 35...minutes with no refills. Not great service and just ok. Would not feel the need to return. Overrated in my opinion.More

It took over an hour to get our food. Once we got it I was disappointed in the tuna as it was cold. The coleslaw was just thrown on the plate and it was extremely unappetizing. My husband ordered the pizza and thought it was...just okay. Wouldn’t eat there again but would go back for a cold beer. Server was okay but if should have set expectations on how long the pizza takes to prepare.More

After hearing such good things about this place from the locals, we were extremely disappointed. We had the lobster spinach dip as an appetizer and it was watery and lacking flavor. We tried a pizza and a burger for entrees and they were fine but...nothing special. It was also quite expensive for what you get in our opinion. I wouldn’t go out of your way to make it here.More

We loved our visit to Big Pine Key and No Name Pub. We planned our visit so that we arrived about 30 minutes or so before dusk in hopes of seeing some key deer on our way in and it worked! Be sure to drive...slow and keep an eye out for them. We saw over a dozen on the way in and out of the key. At No Name Pub we had the Homemade Smoked Fish Dip for an appetizer and it did not disappoint. I ordered a small pizza and had leftover for later. The key lime pie was good too! The service was great! If we return to the keys we'll be back. We were thankful we were able to sit outside. Inside it was typical bar.More

Walked up to the rude guy checking in, knowing we would have a wait. Asked to use the restroom and get a beer. You would of thought with the additive the check in guy that he was doing me a favor!finally got seated, ordered another...beer and it took over 20 minutes to get it. Finally came and the server was acting like she was doing me a favor bring me a beer. Food came, it was good but the experience with employees with an attitude was everlasting. Both my wife and I said ‘I’m done!’ When we got into the car. No name won’t be the Oldest Bar in Key West if this does not get better! It’s a destination at least once a year and we look forward to it.More