Food and service was excellent. Great menu and the pizza was exceptional. We will go back and enjoy the visit
1 - 10 of 104 reviews
Oops, I had it again, and again, and again. My favorite pizza...The Mediterranean. Of course, all the food at this local favorite is fantastic. We love it. The meats, the pizza, the salads, the local, crafted beers...cheers! Joe, Lancaster, PA.
The Miltonian has the best veggie pizza in the area, by far. The top of the pizza is completely covered with a variety of veggies including broccoli and corn. The crust, cheese and sauce are the perfect compliment to the veggies.
I paid $12 for a child size portion of Romaine on my Chicken Caesar salad, I politely asked for more Romaine and was asked if I ate any of the salad in front of me. And was then told I had to pay for another...More
This is the best pizza I've ever eaten. The black olives, olive oil, mozzarella, crumbled feta cheese, oregano, and the tomatoes with other spices make this pie a tasty gem. I got two large ones because we eat whatever is left-over cold the next morning...More
Two visits in 1 week means well worth repeat visits. First visit, spagetti with meat sauce was excellent, Lg serving with leftovers. Second visit, Italian sausage with peppers, onions, cheese, is definitely a do over. Looking forward to more visits.
...always better food. Thanks again for offering up a great pizza...The Mederitterean. Wow. Fulfilling. Tasty. Flavorful. This is my 4th time eating this pizza. This place gets high ratings overall so their other meals are likely outstanding too. (Always skip Grotto's) Eat here instead.
We have had carryout from here before, but this was our first time dining in. Our server was a gem and the pizza was delicious. I needed something healthier, and she was very accommodating, bringing me a delicious Greek salad that suited my needs perfectly....More
The best pizza around & the wings are really good too! We usually get killer and crabby wings and mix them together!
Where I grew up in Corona, Queens NY there was a pick of Italian, family owned and run neighborhood restaurants with the kind of food and atmosphere you had at home. That's what we found at Miltonian! The place was surprisingly large, with comfortable booths...More