The Cottage Cafe is my go to restaurant when I visit Bethany. I just finished a three day stay and went two nights in a row for dinner. The first night everything was absolutely delicious which I have become accustomed to. However, Friday night was...fish fry night which sounded good so I went for it. My suggestion is, stay away from it. There was very little fish inside of a huge amount of crust or breading or whatever you might want to call it, and the second piece, which I thought was fish, was more like mashed potato inside of crust. It could have been all right, but it had a really sour taste. Still not sure what it was. I’ve been many times to the Cottage Cafe and this is the first time that I’ve ever had anything that fell flat. I’ll go back next time I’m in Bethany, just will never have the fish fry.More