I stopped in here for lunch on a Sunday afternoon to get some takeout pizza. We ordered half red potato and half California. The sauce on the pizza is really good and there are definitely a lot of toppings. They make a heavy pizza, so...definitely not a thin crust style. The crust is a little bland but overall its a good pizza. Its also a bit expensive so just keep that in mind.More
Thanks for taking the time for a nice review. Mgr John P.
Super bowl Sunday I ordered a small sausage pepper pizza to go. The length of time to cook was fine. I got it home and cut my piece,only to have everything slide off. Quite a mess. People rave about Willington pizza, not me.More
I am again very sorry about your pizza. I thought we had rectified the situation when we received your initial complaint. We are well aware of what you think about Willington Pizza. It may not be for everyone. Again, we are very sorry. Thank you...More
We went on a Friday evening, with a 2 and 4 yr old. Spacing was pretty tight but the staff was very pleasant and the food was good. They only have wine and beer no full bar. We got two pizzas a cheese w light...sauce for kids and they ate it all up. Then we ordered one with toppings of our choice- we got grilled chicken on it as one topping but I thought the chicken was dry- other than that I enjoyed the pizza. We got poutine as an app but there wasn’t much for cheese curds I saw just lots of gravy- the fries were fresh cut so that was a plus but I wanted the curds. On other days we have ordered take out grinders and have been pleased with taste and quality there. We will keep them on our list to eat fromMore
Thanks for the review and the ffedback! Hope to see you again!
You’ve got to try the dill pickle pizza, ask for it cooked well and cut like a pie. My family was grossed out when I ordered it so we had to order a plain cheese. Well they all tried it and guess which one had...no leftovers. They say it’s different then the one at willington Pizza, I’ve never had theirs and hope WP2 keeps doing it their way, it’s excellent and you can’t eat just one slice.😂More
So glad you liked it and props for trying something new! Thank you for the review
First there are two Willington Pizza houses in Willington: the original Willington Pizza and Willington Pizza Too. The only real difference is size and atmosphere. Too is smaller, more low key and slightly off the beaten path (closer to the highway). Same great food just...quieter and less crowded. The reason to come here is the award winning pizza. It’s pretty awesome! Yes their pizza is not cheap but they really load on the toppings - almost double what other places put on. The pizza is also a thick crust and really good vs the thin NY style. This is one of the few pizza places where I enjoy the crust almost as much of the pizza. WP offers some pretty interesting pies to choose from: Red Potato Pizza, Taco Pizza, The Widow Maker and my new all-time favorite General Tsao’s Chicken Pizza. It sounds pretty weird but trust me, it is pure deliciousness!! Don’t forget to try some of the local craft beers with your meal also. In addition to being a great restaurant they are very supportive of youth sports in their community.More
Thanks for taking the time to write this detailed review, so glad you like everything!
There are many excellent choices for the types of food they serve and some of their specialty pizza are extremely good. However, their prices are not warranted for what they are if you have already tried the food. As an experience, give it a taste....For your regular pizza shop - many equally good choices with better service and lower prices.More
Thanks for the review! We try and keep the prices as fair as possible, fresh quality ingredients are not cheap. Hope to see you again!
The name of the widow maker lives up to its reputation lol 😂 Great pizza with everything needed on it to fill any hungry belly. The old time atmosphere I like. The downfall is the service there. Have been a couple times now and hesitant...on every going back because of the staff being so poorMore
I have been a customer for many years and I must say that the quality of food has been lower than expected in the past two years. The red potatoes pizza is still a good choice.
Decided to stop here after a long day of traveling. The atmosphere here is calm and welcoming, and our waitress was phenomenal! She was extremely talkative and was a pleasure to have a conversation with. Our Italian Wedding pizza was delicious, just what we needed...after a long, tiresome day. I would have loved to stay in the area for one extra day just for the outstanding pizza. Awesome little find, I recommend you do yourself a favor and peep into Willington Pizza Too for a night. You won't be disappointed!More
Willington pizza is where we go for specialty pizza night. The cheeseburger pizza is a must try. It may sound odd, but it's just perfect. There are lots of other choices that are not your average either. I like their taco pizza, but it's very...spicy. Be ready! We usually do take out, but have eaten in and tried the food also. Very yummy and service with a smile.More