We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
All reviews pies thin crust pizza tomato pie potatoes best pizza worth the wait wooster street long wait waiting in line bring cash white clam coal fired oven old school just the right amount pepe's pizza apizza pizzerias
My family and I did the whole pizza run in New Haven. Although we had to wait a bit in the rain to get in (on a Sunday night around 7pm) it was well worth it. The super thin crust pizza was delicious. A large...More
Drove quite a bit out of the way for this place. Waited outside for about 15 minutes. As we were being seated I ordered our pie and drinks. The wait wasn't bad considering the place was packed. The pizza crust was burnt, the regulars will...More
All time All time classic thin crust New Haven pizzaclassic thin crust NewHaven pizza. Simply the best thin crust made by human hands. The recent changes has not impinged on the oven ability to artfully craft all time great pizza not so thin it has...More
We showed up and waited in line for over 45 minutes to get in and to be herded in the door like cattle! It was 45 minutes to get drinks and the pizza shows up after another 30 minutes with burnt crust and missing bacon!...More
Went with my son after seeing this on several TV shows and was REALLY looking forward to it, been to Pepe before and loved it but couldnt get in so we went for "Apizza" (What we call it at home too...LOL) SO DISAPPOINTING!! 45 minute...More
So, of course, your question is: "Was it worth it?"
My answer is, "Yes. Yes, it was." But then I wonder: "Would I do it again?" To which my reflexive response is: "Prob'ly not".
Sally's does pizza, no question about it. I wish I'd known...More
I've been going to Sally's since the 1960's. Pizza at Sally's was a Sunday night tradition in my family, which became a tradition among my friends in the 70s and 80s. Since I've lived out of state, I miss being able to savor that perfect...More
Large mozz $18.50
Add bacon $6.00
Add onion $4.00
Total $28.50 before tax
55 minute wait for the pie after ordering. Maybe 2 slices of bacon on the whole pizza
What seemed like 3 whole onions”way too much”
Barely any mozz!
Should have figured it...More
The great debate over the years was who ruled as the favorite Pizza on Wooster St. Pepe’s or Sally’s? Each had its loyal followers. Truth is they were both excellent and although similar in make up each one had a specialty...More