My husband and I took a very last minute trip to Mystic, and couldn't be happier to find S&P Oyster. Our dining experience was fantastic from beginning to end. We were very happy to see that this restaurant is taking COVID precautions very seriously. Our...temperature was checked when we came in and all tables are sufficiently distanced apart. We were seated in the upstairs dining room by the lovely floor to ceiling windows with a beautiful water view. We ordered a delicious oyster appetizer, scallops and a fantastic shrimp scampi risotto. The waiter and bartender were very attentive and did a great job making sure we had everything we needed. They have a lovely wine list and a full bar too. I cannot find a single complaint about this special restaurant. Everything from the hostess, the waitstaff, food, atmosphere were spectacular. Wish we were staying in the area a bit longer so we could have had another wonderful dining experience at S&P. We will make sure this is our first stop for dinner the next time we are visiting Mystic.More

We made reservations for Valentine’s Day and I am so glad we did! First of all the restaurant is beautiful with wonderful waterfront views. You have the option to dine inside or outside, we chose to dine inside with a beautiful view of the water....The service was exceptional from start to finish. They were helpful with the price fixe menu and were on top of every question and request we had. For starters we had an excellent bottle of red wine-Rioja. For appetizers my girlfriend had the calamari and I had the ceviche. Both appetizers were fresh and delicious. So flavorful! For our second course my girlfriend had the salad and I had the most wonderful cup of lobster bisque. Normally I prefer my bisque on the thicker side but this one was very tasty and left me wanting more. For our entrees we had the salmon and the French cut pork chop, I asked them for veggies instead of the yuca and they were really good. The salmon was cooked perfectly and my pork chop was cooked to the perfect temperature (medium) and was so delicious. We definitely plan on coming back when in the area and hopefully dining at the patio. The menu looks to be packed with so many other great options.More

Food, service, atmosphere are all very good. My husband and I went on Valentine's night where the menu was fixed. Appetizers of oyster toquitos and tuna very fresh and delicious. Second course of lobster bisque and caesar salad tasty. Pork chop and surf and turf...although small was expertly prepared and quite good. Now the but. We understand on Valentine's night many places must limit the menu and, given this Covid environment, we understand paying a little more. In fact it is our responsibility to support the locals. However, $9.50 for a domestic beer, $14.00 for house wine, and $19.50 for a glass of a mass produced bourbon Maker's Mark is excessive and quite frankly wrong. We understand making up lost revenue, but the drink costs took away from an otherwise fine evening. That said, S&P is worth a visit, just be forewarned.More