We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
Tripadvisor gives a Travelers’ Choice award to accommodations, attractions and restaurants that consistently earn great reviews from travelers and are ranked within the top 10% of properties on Tripadvisor.
All reviews filet mignon baked potato vegetarian lasagne bread salad cheesecake friday and saturday limited menu house dressing prime rib night per night sour cream full bar buena vista old building old west great place to eat
Meat lovers heaven. Went here for the prime rib special. No reservations but they seat you pretty quickly. Wait staff was very attentive but busy. Our steaks were made to order but not everyone at our table was pleased with the rareness. Very sizable portions...with plenty to take home. Also had the triple chocolate mousse cake. Easily edible for one.More
It wasn't our first choice, but it turned out to be a good choice. Old saloon decor. During the week your only choice is filet mignon or meatless lasagna. We all opted for the steak. First they brought out a quarter chunk of lettuce with...dressing. Then it was steak and potato and bread. Very good meals for about 15 bucks. Plus your drinks.More
We had eaten at another Quincy in Salida on Prime Rib night and it was very good. This time it was filet mignon and my medium well was more medium rare and the baked potatoes were cold. So I wasn’t impressed with this Quincy’s.
The...old building was very neat as it was in Historic Leadville.
This restaurant only has one thing on the menu some nights are filet and some nights prime rib. So don’t go there looking for a choice.More
Sorry but the 9 oz. filet was below average. Very tough to cut and chew. Nice server replaced them for us and new ones were only slightly better. Didn’t finish it. Good salad. Baked potatoes were hard but OK. Every other booth was not used....Noticed that after use that tables, chairs and menus were wiped down. Haven’t had very good luck with steaks in the past so we gave it another try but I think that I am done. I would rather pay more and get a good steak.More
Everything is different because of COVID, of course. All staff wore masks, but didn't enforce people waiting to wear any. The steak was not as good as I'd expected, was only average. But I judge places on how well they treat singles, and I was...treated to a nice table and good service.More
We have always loved it here. This time it was even better! We brought some family members who never tried it. They were so impressed! The service, food, drinks, absolute perfection! We will definitely be back!!
We visited Quincey’s our last night in town and had a great experience there. The food is really solid plus the atmosphere is pretty cool. Would definitely go back anytime I had a hankering for steak when in Leadville.
We had to travel across Colorado for a funeral and stopped in Buena Vista for a meal. Finding a good restaurant is doubly difficult in these times and this place is a gem. They have a very simple menu - Monday hrs Thursday only Filet...Mignon of several sizes and on Friday and Saturday only Prime Rib. We both like rare beef and it is very difficult to get rare prime rib - but Quincy’s did it to perfection. Great food, our server Victoria was wonderful and the price was outstanding.More
I went here for dinner and it was one of the best fillets I have ever had. They have 4 different sizes and so there is one for every appetite. For the price, it is unbelievable how good this fillet was.