We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
On our website fundiegofamily.com we are looking for the best pizza in San Diego. Coney's is currently at number 4 for NY-style pizza. Coney's serves a classic NY-style thin crust. It has only a few tables and is best for takeout.
Coney Island Pizzeria has gone through a number of changes. When they started out 10 or so years ago they were further east off Poway Rd. There were a number of partners and employees who came and went. The place itself was nothing to look...More
1st of all, Coney Island Pizzeria has moved to 12233 Poway Road. I ordered a plain pie and it was average at best. I was excited to try it (hopeful it would be good) at the new location because about 10 years ago when Sonny...More
If you like thin crust pizza, Coney Island is for you. They hand toss their dough and bake it in a genuine pizza oven to a crisp perfection. My personal favorite is "The Truth." It features 2 types of cured meats, ricotta, mozzarella, and feta...More
Adela's Seafood & Mexican has opened up in their place. Great food. Rice portion could be a little larger and served hotter; enchilada sauce could have a bit more kick but we really enjoyed their food;). Bienvenidos to the neighborhood!
Date of visit: September 2016
Elmer R, Owner at Coney Island Pizzeria, responded to this reviewResponded October 4, 2016
This is a very small family pizzaria, nothing fancy, but we believe really good thin crust pizza, no grease. We usually have "The Big Apple" (NYC). Very good and quick. They have a small tap with local beers as well. Give them a shot, I...More
It wasn't bad but wasn't great either. They have only one size pizza, which is a first for me! Also the wings don't use your standard buffalo suuce, but more of a dry rub and where slightly under cooked.
This is the place you come for a great New York style thin crust pizza with fresh, homemade toppings spread generously across the pie. We live in Lakeside and make the trip out here on the average of twice a month. Their crust is absolutely...More